If I were to buy a Porsche, I think it would be a Cayman. I like the Boxter, and the Cayman is essentially a Boxter coupe. Convertibles are nice to have at the right time and place. But that's not most times and most places. Coupes are more practical, comfortable, quiet, safe, and theft-resistant. They are also lighter for a given degree of structural stiffness, so they can have a better combo of ride and handling.