Well, pick a Miami QB from 86-92. Testaverde, Walsh, Erickson, Toretta.
Matt Leinart was another one. Probably a lot of FSU’s QBs during their great run from 87-2000. Ward, Kanell, Wills, Weinke. Every Bama QB since Saban has been the there.
Ohio St and UGA QBs the last few years. Not that any of these guys weren’t good players in their own right but they were all surrounded by talent everywhere.
Okay, so this would make me want to rank each school's QBs in terms of perceived talent. I'll just take Bama QBs under Saban. They've all been blessed with great defenses, great college RBs, great everything, as you've noted. Here they are:
07, 08 - John Parker Wilson
09, 10 - Greg McElroy
11-13 - AJ McCarron
14 - Blake Sims
15 - Jake Coker
16, 17 - Jalen Hurts
18, 19 - Tua Tagovailoa
20 - Mac Jones
.
Saban obviously has changed his offensive tactics since 2018. Judging by talent and not citing stats, I'd rank them:
Tua, McCarron, Jones, Sims, Wilson, McElroy, Hurts, Coker
.
I guess when I think of Dorsey on Miami - he wasn't a weak link necessarily, but he was the weakest link of the team. I don't think Tua was the weakest link of his Bama teams (injuries notwithstanding)...McCarron may have been in '11, but not after that. I think, career-wise, maybe from Sims-on (in my rankings), you could say they were all the weakest links.
So it's not 100%, but after the first couple, yeah.