Edelman's HoF argument is he won 3sbs and was clutch in SB. His career marks are completely pedestrian. Zero pro bowls. Non current HOFer Roger Craig would like a word with that argument. His 3 rings, 7 sb TDs, not to mention 500+ catches and 8,000 yds rushing have counted for jack. I'm sure there are others too (Ward, Holt, Wayne, etc)
Bob Horry won a pile of rings. Big whoop. Madison was lights out in his several WS starts but appears headed for a 'nice' career, but not remotely close to HOF.