I was looking on cfreference and their SRS ratings. I really like it. It strips away all the crap that doesn't matter and deals only with what happens on the field.
Who did you play and how did you do?
Many people here seem to think I don't care about results....when that's all I care about. I care about what a team does and who they do it against. I don't give a shit how many draft picks they have or star ratings, etc.
But yes, a win over a good team is better than a win over a bad team.
A blowout is better than a close win.
Best win/worst loss isn't where SOS begins and ends, sorry.
.
All that being said, I listed national champions out by SOS and also listed the highest or next-highest of each season.
What I like about this is that it doesn't care about legendary status or mystique or even general consensus.
I started with 1966, as integration was happening and the top 3 teams that year were clustered.
.
What do we see?
1971 Nebraska was the best team ever.
What they did vs who they played was #1 of all-time, by a healthy margin.
After them? There's a cluster.
72 USC, 70 Texas, 70 Nebraska, and 2020 Alabama.
At first I thought it was an era thing, but no, late-60s teams didn't show up here. There just happened to be a few amazing teams around then. Plus 20 Bama, with the undefeated, no-cupcakes schedule.
Makes sense.
74 OU
95 Nebraska
No surprises there.
Another cluster after that: 77 ND, 91 Washington, 01 Miami, 18 Clemson
No big surprises there.
78 Bama, 04 USC, 66 ND
19 LSU
73 ND, 08 Florida, 22 Georgia
Yeah, 2019 LSU had an all-time great offense, maybe the best ever. But their defense wasn't great for a NC. They had a 3-point win. A 5-point win. That matters.
05 Texas, 23 Michigan
93 FSU
88 ND, 11 Bama, 12 Bama
.
Okay, that's enough listing them from the top. The bottom?
By far the worst, c'mon, all together now: 84 BYU
BY FAR.
Next worst? 2002 OSU. I was ready to comment here about how that team's win over Miami was one of the biggest upsets ever, but turns out 02 Miami wasn't 01 Miami.
07 LSU.....2 losses, we get it. Not great.
92 Bama. Everyone remembers the great D, no one wants to talk about the QB throwing 5 TDs and 14 INTs.
90 CU and 90 GT
80 Georgia
Next worst: 06 Florida, 98 Tennessee, 83 Miami, 97 Michigan, 16 Clemson
Some ranked in the lower third that might surprise you: 85 OU, 67 USC, 66 MSU, 94 Nebraska
.
Okay, now for the non-champs.
By far and away the top non-NC is 1973 OU. 71 OU would be the guess here, and they're 2nd, but it's a big gap.
Another big gap.
2019 OSU. Rated above 2019 LSU. Hmmph.
72 OU, 94 Penn St (robbed and robbed badly)
78 USC, 16 Bama
18 Bama, 81 PSU, 05 USC, 76 Michigan, 08 OU, 68 Texas
77 Bama, 80 Pitt (duh)
Lots of Bamas and OSUs and OUs and USCs litter the list.
For the lower end:
07 WV....fun team to watch, resume is light in the pants
67 ND, 21 Michigan
84 Florida, 04 Auburn
06 USC, 23 Texas
22 Michigan, 15 OSU
.
Some notes:
80 UGA was 9th in SRS in 1980. But they had the magical zero in the loss column.
I thought 99 and 13 FSU would rank highly, but they're middle-of-the-pack for NCs.
90 Miami was leaps and bounds ahead of either 90 NC
04 Utah was actually ranked 2nd-best of that season.
BYU winning in 84 was criminal. The gap between them and the top team that year (Florida) is the same as the gap between 95 Nebraska and 81 Clemson.
I've never thought much of the 80s Penn St teams, but the NCs rate average and 81 non-NC even higher. I stand corrected.
I was thinking 86 Miami would be a high non-NC, but they weren't in the top 2 that year (OU ranks ahead of them, despite the h2h loss). But 88 Miami does rank highly, so 88 Miami > 86 Miami
Similar thing for 95 Florida....95 OSU ranks higher.
Wisconsin ranks as the #1 team in 2017, so hats off to them. In that light, they remind me of 2000 OU, with a better RB.
.
Any thoughts? Criticisms?