Maybe let's just try getting the wealthy to pay some taxes. You know, the ones worth billions of dollars with no actual income. Let's get them to throw in some money and see what happens.
This, IMHO, is a major part of the problem.
Back in 1980 Democratic Presidential Candidate Walter Mondale said that taxes would have to be increased whether he or Ronal Reagan was President. He tried to make it an honesty issue by adding "He won't tell you so, I just did."
Back then, my impression is that Democrats were not so solely focused on "raising taxes on the rich".
I'm not exactly blaming Democrats, it obviously didn't work out for Mondale. Subsequently Clinton promised a Middle Class Tax cut, then didn't deliver it saying that it just wasn't possible. He had promised to only raise taxes on "the rich" but when he got in office it turned out that anyone with a job was apparently "rich".
The problem with the focus on raising taxes on "the rich" is that it doesn't work for a multitude of reasons including:
- Democrats rarely actually do it. Their donors are rich so it tends to get de-prioritized after elections.
- Wealthier people have greater flexibility. If you raise say the SS Tax rate people at the bottom and in the middle pretty much have to pay. Their only alternative is to not work. People at the high end aren't impacted so much because of the cap (~$176k/yr) and because a lot of them can move income from active (pays SS) to passive (doesn't pay SS).
- On the flexibility front: As @Cincydawg pointed out, a number of European countries dropped their wealth taxes because the wealthy can do things like tax avoidance (legal), tax evasion (illegal), or just simply move to a lower-tax jurisdiction.
As I see it the situation today is that Republicans talk about cutting spending but then when they get in office they only make, at most, miniscule cuts. Democrats talk about raising taxes on the rich but then when they get in office they only make, at most, miniscule increases in revenue. Meanwhile Republicans do keep their tax cut promises and Democrats do keep their spending promises so spending keeps going up.