I am somewhat tempted by the C8 Vette, convertible, but I always think I would never drive it anywhere near its capabilities.
I don't drive the GTI near its capabilities. I like having the extra "cushion" if I get into a curve a bit too fast or need to punch it to merge etc.
For me, having a manual is a good step to making a car fun to drive, even in the city. The valet at the French restaurant can't drive a stick, so when he sees us, he just smiles and points to the lot.
I give him five bucks anyway. He's a nice kid.
The GTI really is hard to beat for our needs, which are modest, the spaciousness is handy when we trek to Costco.