Hell, the last time (based on composite ranking) WV produced a 4* recruit was OG Josh Jenkins in 2008 (who went to WVU), and there were two years in there without a 3*.
Before that, WR Brandon Barnett in 2004, who also went to WVU.
TE R.J. Coleman in 2002 who went to OSU, but I've never actually heard of him.
Actually Gwaltney went to WVU, but wasn't from West Virginia. As far back as the composite rankings go, WV hasn't produced a 5*