CFB51 College Football Fan Community
The Power Four => SEC => Topic started by: MikeDeTiger on September 28, 2026, 10:16:30 AM
-
One-third of the way through the regular season, I thought we could do one like the B1G board does for their conference. Pretty shoddy effort here, I haven't watched the majority of the games, so just re-arrange/post your own, no need to quibble with this list, I know it sucks.
- UGA--Still the bully on the block until proven otherwise. SEC Champs 3 of the last 4 years.
- UT (Arch Manning variety)--best resume, easily. Dinged them a little bit for the inability to whip UGA recently.
- Bama--dammit. Just die already.
- UF--letdown, schmetdown. UM is at least a quality team, and Gator just treated them like a season-opening warmup.
- UT (Peyton Manning variety)--good showing against #2, came up just short at home.
- Ole Miss--playing on the road is hard. Ran into a buzzsaw. Or a Baughzsaw. Probably better than this, but this performance hurts.
- LSU--Nice bounceback, but quality wins are a question and the injuries to crucial stars are piling up.
- Clanga--needed a comeback against what I perceive is a below-average Mizzou squad, but undefeated.
- UK--Win against A&M doesn't look as good now. But good chance to move up in two weeks by knocking off the #7 Tigers.
- Mizzou--played Clanga tough, but not a lot to hang their hat on. Win against a not-good Kansas team is their best.
- AU--tough to get a read on this team.
- OU--can't believe I'm putting them this low. They don't look ok, though.
- A&M--surprisingly bad so far. Not really one thing holding them back, they need improvement in a lot of areas.
- USC--can at least blow out cupcakes
- Vandy--life is tough, post-Diego.
- Woo pigs--pretty rough, so far.
-
Pretty much agree across the board with MDT. I'll make it a little easier on myself.
Georgia
.
.
Texas, Alabama, Florida
.
Tennessee
.
LSU, Ole Miss
.
.
Kentucky, Mizzou
.
.
.
The rest in no particular order
.
.
.
Pigs
-
1. UGA (still the standard)
2. Texas (Elite defense, Arch average)
3. Florida (taking on the personality of Sumerall. I think they hired a good one)
4. LSU (OM blemish was destiny, I still believe)
5. Ole Miss (As Golding gets entrenched, I think they fall off considerably....lucky he has Chambliss)
6. Bama (Winning, but something still doesn't feel right. Fear factor -- gonzo)
7. Miss St. (what TN was in 2021/2022 -- same coaching tree -- the right QB is essential and they have it)
8. Tennessee (defense looks much improved, Frosh QB, ultra conservative coaching limiting the team)
9. Mizzou (always scrappy, even when I feel like they should get run over)
10. Kentucky (Stein looks to have instilled confidence in the Cats. Pulled some key portal players)
11. TAM (Reed, always inflated, never that good. Elko overrated?)
12. Oklahoma (Venables has set the offense back 50 years. Mateer the biggest fraud in recent memory)
13. Auburn (nothing to get exited about here. Just blah)
14. S. Carolina (nice knowing you Beamer, you little twerp. Good riddance. Totally blown the Sellers years)
15. Vandy (it's Vandy. Lea a good coach, nothing to work with. F'em)
16. Arkansas (pathetic. Terrible team, terrible coaching hire, terrible administration = terrible in perpetuity)
-
Forget the Power Rankings, how 'bout the Pisser Rankings? Texas is clearly #1 on that list.
-
Forget the Power Rankings, how 'bout the Pisser Rankings? Texas is clearly #1 on that list.
Dunno, last week Tom Brady said Dak Prescott "fired an absolute piss-missile," so the Cowboys might be #1.
Or I guess we're just talking SEC here?
-
3. Florida (taking on the personality of Sumerall. I think they hired a good one)
Dammit
-
Dammit
Agreed.
-
.
.
.
The rest in no particular order
.
.
.
Not even bothering to mention OU by name......the final insult.
Approved!
-
Dammit
Well, we're about due, aren't we? We couldn't be hiring Gerry DiNardos and David Shulas forever, lol.
-
I raise you one Charlie Strong and Tom Herman.
Actually Tom Herman wasn't a terrible football coach, he was just a terrible human being.
-
I raise you one Charlie Strong and Tom Herman.
Actually Tom Herman wasn't a terrible football coach, he was just a terrible human being.
I'll raise all of you and toss in--- a 1 year Kiffin, Derek Dooley, Butch Jones, Jeremy Pruitt.
-
Yeah I think you win.
-
Dudes.
If we're talking terrible coaches and terrible human beings, I give you Ed Orgeron.
This isn't close.
-
Dudes.
If we're talking terrible coaches and terrible human beings, I give you Ed Orgeron.
This isn't close.
He won a Championship, so despite him being him, he is excluded from this conversation IMO.
-
Yeah I think you win.
Sometimes when you win, you lose.....a lot..... for a long time.
-
Agree. No coach that wins the national championship belongs in this discussion.
-
But we're factoring in terrible human beings, not just coaching ability.
O may not have invented the bagman, but he perfected it long before he ever got to LSU. He lied about Texas' A/C not working in the locker rooms. He went nuts, leaving his wife of many years, sleeping around, posting photos of his sexual escapades on social media, and propositioning the wives of members of the BoR (yes, he really did that), and was run out on a rail for it.
That doesn't even touch his coaching "prowess." Which is what most people think he was fired for, thought it wasn't (see above). Okay......won a NC, fine. But given the entirety of his tenure, it's pretty obvious that he fell ass-backwards through no intelligence, design, or intention of his own into one of the greatest QBs the sport ever saw, and one of the best receiver tandems to boot. Getting mind-numblingly lucky is not skill, and it's not a recipe for long term success. Which is why he ran both Ole Miss and LSU into the ground. He couldn't even get coordinators to come work for him by the end, getting rejected by four different DCs he attempted to hire before finally, desperately getting a guy who had never coached defense anywhere close to the LSU level. And this is at a school that had recently passed the $2 mil mark for paying coordinators, leading the nation. How toxic and worthless do you have to be if people won't come to a school known for defensive talent, with a recruiting hotbed, for $2 mil per year?
When talking about terrible coaches and terrible human beings, I feel like I've made a very strong case for him.
Also.......we hired him back on this staff, so........geaux us, I guess.
-
Forget it man, he's not in the conversation. You have some coaches that are, but he ain't one of 'em.
Tom Herman is a terrible human being and also had a team that lost to Kansas and he never sniffed a national championship. That's why he's in the conversation.
-
Forget it man, he's not in the conversation. You have some coaches that are, but he ain't one of 'em.
Tom Herman is a terrible human being and also had a team that lost to Kansas and he never sniffed a national championship. That's why he's in the conversation.
There is no LSU coach that approaches him. Archer, Hallman, and DiNardo were all terrible, but at least they comported themselves well. Orgeron doesn't even have that. And three of his five seasons weren't any better than what those dweebs put on the field.
I guess I need to know more about Tom Herman and why he's a terrible human being. Did he go Art Biles/Hugh Freeze or something?
-
Skeezy affairs, hiding things from his family and the university, total dick to his assistants and the team and pretty much everyone. Just a real scumbag, which is the main reason why he was fired, but the losing to Kansas and generally poorly disciplined and unmotivated teams didn't help.
Anyway, the whole point is, we're talking about coaches who sucked, and I also mentioned Tom Herman being a bad person. Ed O won a national championship. He is not a part of that same conversation.
-
Joe Burrow, Joe Brady/Steve Ensminger, and Dave Aranda won a national championship.
Ed O is the luckiest sumbitch who ever lived who happened to be along for the ride. We saw what he was made out of before and after those people left him. Ole Miss and LSU are......not impressed.
However, I can see the point from an outsider's perspective.
-
Sometimes when you win, you lose.....a lot..... for a long time.
Sometimes you get a lose/lose.
Closest thing I can think of for comparison.....Les Miles, when he was fired, I reluctantly agreed that it was time for him to go. Not a fan of the way we did it, but I thought it was most likely time.
I was wondering if you thought the same thing about Fulmer. From an outside perspective, I didn't blame UT for letting him go. Even looking back at the carousel UT put itself on as a result of that, I'm not sure it was the thing to do to keep him longer.
Seems like you can be bit right on the ass in the crazy coaching market, searching for that perfect fit, and yet still have been right in firing the previous coach and entering that crazy market that takes a piece out of your derriere.
-
Sometimes you get a lose/lose.
Closest thing I can think of for comparison.....Les Miles, when he was fired, I reluctantly agreed that it was time for him to go. Not a fan of the way we did it, but I thought it was most likely time.
I was wondering if you thought the same thing about Fulmer. From an outside perspective, I didn't blame UT for letting him go. Even looking back at the carousel UT put itself on as a result of that, I'm not sure it was the thing to do to keep him longer.
Seems like you can be bit right on the ass in the crazy coaching market, searching for that perfect fit, and yet still have been right in firing the previous coach and entering that crazy market that takes a piece out of your derriere.
My comment on we "win", was we had the most crappy coaches hired in succession -- meaning we won but didn't want to.
Fulmer, in hindsight, yes -- it turned out to be a huge mistake to let him go when we did, but moreso HOW we did it. He was 1 year removed from playing for the SEC Championship in 2007, against LSU, as I trust you remember.
Anyway, I think the UT brass had a unrealistic view of the program's national standing, thinking we could just go get whoever we wanted and that turned out to be catastrophic, and they went willy nilly into the deal without any sort of plan. They should have gauged interest behind the scenes, and 'had' their man as it were, before pulling the trigger.
That error only set us back 15 years. Ugh.
-
The worse hire from the time it was made was Tennessee and Derek Dooley. Dude was sub-.500 at Louisiana Tech, FFS. Coming off a 4-8 season, HE GOT THE TENNESSEE JOB.
Nothing comes close to comparing.
-
The worse hire from the time it was made was Tennessee and Derek Dooley. Dude was sub-.500 at Louisiana Tech, FFS. Coming off a 4-8 season, HE GOT THE TENNESSEE JOB.
Nothing comes close to comparing.
Yeah, that was strange, weird, and dumb. The only thing I can think of is that the Kiffin-whirlwind-disaster-tornado happening so quickly on the heels of moving on from Fulmer put them in a dizzying pickle they were unprepared for.
Ole Miss got the sequel to that movie, and LSU, you'll get to see the trilogy's finalewith a private screening at some point, I suspect.
fwiw, I only offered Orgeron in this conversation for consideration due to somebody saying "terrible human being." On coaching merits alone, yeah, he's a shitty coach, but I don't think he stands a real chance of winning the category. He's only a contender in the All-Around Schmuck Olympics. I don't know that he can out-schmuck Herman, Dooley, etc., but he's the best we've got to offer.
Mind you......Curly Hallman was so fantastically inept as a coach, he could almost make the field even as an upstanding citizen. Every LSU fan should hate Brett Favre for obfuscating that fact.
-
Yeah, that was strange, weird, and dumb. The only thing I can think of is that the Kiffin-whirlwind-disaster-tornado happening so quickly on the heels of moving on from Fulmer put them in a dizzying pickle they were unprepared for.
Ole Miss got the sequel to that movie, and LSU, you'll get to see the trilogy's finalewith a private screening at some point, I suspect.
fwiw, I only offered Orgeron in this conversation for consideration due to somebody saying "terrible human being." On coaching merits alone, yeah, he's a shitty coach, but I don't think he stands a real chance of winning the category. He's only a contender in the All-Around Schmuck Olympics. I don't know that he can out-schmuck Herman, Dooley, etc., but he's the best we've got to offer.
Mind you......Curly Hallman was so fantastically inept as a coach, he could almost make the field even as an upstanding citizen. Every LSU fan should hate Brett Favre for obfuscating that fact.
It's this:
"The only thing I can think of is that the Kiffin-whirlwind-disaster-tornado happening so quickly on the heels of moving on from Fulmer put them in a dizzying pickle they were unprepared for."
Kiffin bolted Jan. 12th after the coaching carousel was over. There were no good choices. And we proved it.
-
The worse hire from the time it was made was Tennessee and Derek Dooley. Dude was sub-.500 at Louisiana Tech, FFS. Coming off a 4-8 season, HE GOT THE TENNESSEE JOB.
Nothing comes close to comparing.
Bryan Harsin at Auburn was a pretty dumb clown show.
-
Hate to speak ill of the departed, but were any of these yahoos 0-77 bad? No? Then STFU.
Carry on.
-
No, but we did lose to Troy in 2017, which was the worst thing I've seen since the 90's. Both Saban and then Miles toyed around with the idea of losing to Troy, but then thought better of it and mounted furious 4th quarter comebacks. Ogre was the first one we had who actually decided, yeah, let's do this.
-
No, but we did lose to Troy in 2017, which was the worst thing I've seen since the 90's. Both Saban and then Miles toyed around with the idea of losing to Troy, but then thought better of it and mounted furious 4th quarter comebacks. Ogre was the first one we had who actually decided, yeah, let's do this.
Yep, then later in the year you beat A&M for like the 5th time in a row.
-
I think the week after the Troy loss we went to Florida and beat them.
I hated losing to Troy, but I enjoyed the hilarity afforded by UF losing to a team that just got pantsed at home by a mid-major.
iirc, both those teams sucked. I think I made a post that year about how LSU/UF used to be must-see TV, and now it was "I want to look away but can't" TV.