Perhaps the BEST B1G Forum anywhere, here at College Football Fan Site, CFB51!!!

FSU's defense is about as good as Iowa's; plus they have offensive players, Iowa doesn't. Easily a Top 10 team. They are undefeated. Rodemaker will be available for playoffs. Top 4 team for playoffs, if FSU wins tonight.

Yeah, but my nonsense is based in fact. Those are the four best teams on SP+, which is an actual objective metric. What you want is objectivity when it favors you, and subjectivity when it favors you. You have no actual guidelines, just whatever you think at the time. Which is, at least, how we pick the playoff field, at least for this last year.

Why is pretending the current FSU team is the same one as a month ago a good idea?  
Why is denying truth good?
If you're the loudest voice of dissention, I'm more confident in my opinion.

Remember- FSU you see now is not the team you would see in the playoffs. 

The defense is, and they look superb. 

The offense would be their 2nd string QB who had already shown he can lead them to a high point output. 

No undefeated conf champ has ever been left out.  If you do that now you really are saying the outcomes don’t count.

Besides that, nobody can agree on who the best 4 teams are.  It’s totally subjective. 

I'll never understand this argument for anything.

Why is pretending the current FSU team is the same one as a month ago a good idea? 
Why is denying truth good?
If you're the loudest voice of dissention, I'm more confident in my opinion.

Why do you think it's your job to pretend when the results are right there on the field?

This argument will stay so circular. 

OAM will hammer the point that the world should be a certain way. He will argue as if any other outlook is blasphemy.

How do you spell point out more conventional logic and he will roll his eyes and rage against it. And it’ll end with whatever happens. 

My gut is the folks that decide this won’t have the guts to do something that dramatic. Maybe they will. They’ve basically never done something daring, but maybe this time. 

Actually, no.

From the CFP's own website:




This is absolutely NOT a case of OAM raging and being crazy.  I'm simply going by WHAT THE COMMITTEE says their job is.

PLEASE tell me how I'm wrong now.  This is called evidence.  Please, please, get creative and sweep THIS under the rug.

Actually, no.

From the CFP's own website:




This is absolutely NOT a case of OAM raging and being crazy.  I'm simply going by WHAT THE COMMITTEE says their job is.

PLEASE tell me how I'm wrong now.  This is called evidence.  Please, please, get creative and sweep THIS under the rug.

TCU wasn’t one of the four best teams last season, but they earned it based on results and surprised everyone by beating Michigan.  FSU without its starting QB isn’t one of the best 4 but will have earned it with a 13-0 record.