Fact: Courtney claims she was abused
No one doubts.
fact: her own mother says she was not, and she made it clear she would bring Urban down
You conveniently ignore that she earlier DOCUMENTED in text messages that he did abuse Courtney and was happy to reveal those to a journalist *after* she made contrary claims to Snook (the least credible journalist involved).
Fact: Zach mom gives eyewitness accounts of Courtney getting drunk and starting physical altercations, and even trying to run him over
Let's have me accept that as true. Even then, it's in zero way germane to Urban and whether Zach deserved his job. As mentioned, Courtney could in theory be the most batshit crazy lady in Ohio and also be a victim of serial abuse and Zach, for that alone, will have not deserved his job. Whether she's crazy and even did illegal things of her own, therefore, is not an important data point.
It's a pure distraction tactic.
Fact: police never found a reason to arrest him, until the trespassing.
Excluding 2009 and his DUI, that's true. But it's again irrelevant. After 2009, Urban's responsibilities had a lower burden of proof. He had to care about all rumors. He also had responsibility to build an environment in which, especially when "everybody knew" (Ramzy), to not hide a serial abuser and permit such a subordinate to thrive.
It is only you in this debate who has the arrogance to say what you just said. You heard the side of the story that is most appealing for the world you desire.
Come on, irony.
Just because a person claims to be a victim does not mean they are, or that they are being honest.
But you choose to take it as gospel, and completely rationalize away any other versions of what happened.
Again, you conveniently continue to sidestep what the owner/creator and lead author of the most popular buckeye website has said:
"Literally everybody knew. I knew. I wrote around it for six years."
I doubt anyone here is buying your fake outrage at me, nor does any person who has read my opinion think I am piling on the victim.
Fake? Huh?
Outrage? Huh?
Self-righteous? On this topic? I figured I'd been pretty calm. Even spent overmany posts railing on the ills of PC culture in this discussion's offing.
Flippant? Ah, well, yeah that one could deffffinitely be me.
Anyway: If that's how you feel, there's not much I can do for you pal. Whether you want to engage is your call.