Man, Bobby Lane was something special in his time. But there are a lot of names on this list that have likely eclipsed him. Gonna take some thought, but I'm glad you included him, he at least deserves a mention.
For some of these I've really got to go back and separate their college careers from their pro careers, Emmitt Smith being a prime example. I recall him being very good in coilege, but my impression of his overall achievement is definitely affected by his fantastic pro career.