Yes, and a lot of that depends when you were born, in comparison to how your school has done during your viewing lifetime.
I may be among the worst "mighty" Gators fans, because my viewing lifetime began the same year Spurrier started at Florida. My few college football memories pre-1990 weren't necessarily of Florida football.
So I've seen all of UF's NCs, 2 Heismans, all of the SEC titles, and a top 3 program overall, nationally. So that's my baseline as we inch forward. Yes, a 9-3 regular season being considered good or over-achieving feels odd.