I guess one of the questions would be if you give more weight to a guy who excels at both kickoff and punt returns vs one who is better at one of them individually. I think touchdowns also gets weighed significantly in the general perception. Egbuka did not have any. That is definitely impressive that he racked up so many yards without scoring on a return. In the end, I voted for Charlie Jones, and I think it is the opposite of a homer pick in some ways since he transferred from Iowa to Purdue after spring ball. I was not a big fan of that move, but I still anticipate him having good punt and kickoff return numbers this year and better receiving numbers (sigh, Iowa offense).