Honorable Mentions (got a vote or more):
QB - Staubach, Newton, Elway, McNair
RB - Doak Walker, Walter Payton, Jim Brown, Red Grange, Tony Dorsett, Reggie Bush
WR - Tim Brown, Calvin Johnson, Michael Irvin, Fred Biletnikoff, Lynn Swann, Kirk Gibson, Roy Williams, Peter Warrick
TE - Keith Jackson, Heath Miller, Tony Gonzalez
C - Barrett Jones, Dick Butkus, Dominic Raiola
G/T - Joe Thomas, Maurkice Pouncey, Lincoln Kennedy, John Hicks, Aaron Taylor (UNL), Jake Long
-------
DE/DT - Leon Hart, David Pollack, Steve Emtman, Merlin Olson, Ted Hendricks, Bronko Nagurski, Mike Reid, Terrell Suggs, Julius Peppers, Bruce Smith
LB - Derrick Brooks, Hugh Green?, Jack Ham, Pat Fitzgerald, Manti T'eo, Brian Bosworth, Lawrence Taylor, Luke Kuechly, Wilbur Marshall, Chris Spielman, Brian Urlacher
CB - Patrick Peterson, Roger Wehril, Terence Newman, Dre Bly, Darrell Green, Terrell Buckley
S - Roy Williams, Donnie Shell, Kenny Easley, Jack Tatum, Bennie Blades
-------
K - Art Carmody, Kevin Butler, Mason Crosby, Zane Gonzalez
P - Daniel Sepulveda, Johnny Townsend, Reggie Roby, Tom Hackett, Russell Erxleben
KR - Desmond Howard, Tim Brown, Ted Ginn Jr, C.J. Spiller, Willie Gault
PR - Deion Sanders, Ted Ginn Jr, C.J. Spiller, Raghib Ismail, Devin Hester, David Allen, Wes Welker
AP - Christian McCaffrey, Jim Thorpe, Marshall Faulk, Darren Sproles, Charles Woodson, Tim Brown
Players in blue are on this list because of their NFL exploits (or MLB, ffs).