Anyway, back on topic - I decided to do all-star teams by decade.
So far, I've made:
1970s OSU
1990s Florida
2000s Texas
1980s Miami
.
The next obvious ones are 2010s Alabama, 1990s Nebraska, 1990s FSU, 1970s OU, and on and on.
I'm using their stats from the whole decade, so their defensive ratings aren't all maxed-out, which is a good thing.