CFB51 College Football Fan Community

The Power Five => Big Ten => Topic started by: Gigem on November 05, 2023, 03:29:23 PM

Title: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Gigem on November 05, 2023, 03:29:23 PM
Posting this on the B1G forum because it has the most traffic.  

Some of you may know that I work for a large multinational corporation and I also have a side business.  I just passed the 20 year mark with my company, feels like a big whoop-dee-doo nothing to tell you the truth.  

I'm currently 47, about to be 48 in a month.  20 years of service, I was checking my retirement benefits and to tell you the truth I'm not sure what I'm working for anymore.  This is the last year our company will contribute to our pension, after 2023 they will not contribute anything more to our pension and instead put extra money in our 401K.  

I have mixed feelings about this, mainly because they are changing the game on me 2/3rds of the way through.  For the younger workers I can see how this will be a great benefit to them.  They are also starting to count OT and bonuses in the contribution as well.  Right now I'm sitting at about $500K in my 401, which ain't bad, but if they had counted my OT and bonuses through the years I'm convinced I would have closer to 1 MM.  

At one time my company, like so many other large companies in past times offered great retirement benefits.  They started backing these down in the 1980's and 90's, and now I don't think they offer anything at all beyond a company sponsored 401K plan.  No health insurance options, no pension for anybody hired within the last few years, almost nothing.  

The job I have now is somewhat low-level, but it is the best job in terms of work-life balance I have had in my whole career.  I usually work about 40 hours a week, one day every two weeks from home, and every other Friday off.  I make low 100's, but I've made 30-40K more in the recent past with overtime.  I don't want that life anymore, and I chose this job so I would have more regular hours.  But to tell you the truth the pay really sucks in my opinion, especially when you've got 20 years with the company and you know that you're only making maybe 20-30 more than most new hires off the street (I do have a degree FYI, but it's not necessarily a job that requires a degree).  

Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Gigem on November 05, 2023, 03:38:15 PM
With my side business occupying more and more of my time I've been looking hard at leaving early and doing this full time.  

Right now, depending on how I take my pension I can probably get about $2-3K per month.  But it all depends on how long I defer it, if I take spousal survivorship for my wife (she has never worked outside the home), and if I take the option where you get more money until SS kicks in and then it levels out.  None of these options excite me, and as I stated after this year it will never get better.  The only real game changer is how long I defer it.  

Health insurance is pretty bad as well, and I'm not even sure I can get anything unless I retire at 50 or older.  So looking at the info I have it looks like I'd pay about $1,200 per month for a high deductible plan if I retire at 50, and if I had 30 years of service it would go down to about $800 until Medicare kicks in.  This would be for both me and my wife.  I'm not even sure if this is any better than what I could find on the open market if I bought it myself.  

The main kicker to the health insurance question is that our company offered something called a RHCAP where you would kick in a little money every month to a savings plan and when you retire the company would match 100% of the money in there.  I think I have about $20K in mine (they made it hard to log in and changed the plan so many times I have not logged in in awhile).  They stopped that about 2 years ago.  The kicker is you have to be 50 to get the match.  If I leave early I will get my money back, but no match.  

Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on November 05, 2023, 03:40:55 PM
I hit a wall about then in my career.  I basically started mailing it in, I did what was necessary, not an iota more, for probably 15 years.  It was a "hunker down" situation for me, I had three kids to put through college etc.  I despised work, and many of my coworkers (some were OK).  When 2008 hit, I figured I'd have to work another 5 years over my "plan" to make up for it, but things came back quicker than I thought.

Before that, I felt like I had a "career" with some incentives for working, after that, it was just work.  I couldn't quit, I couldn't find another job, I was just stuck.

In 2013 they came out with retirement packages for folks at my level, but excluded those of us on the technical side of things as we were "too valuable".  I was PO'd.  My buddy told me to stick around and it would happen for us, and it did six months later.  I was glad to be done of it.  I should write a book.

P.S.  Every year you work is a year you don't have to "cover" with your retirement.  And you'll likely need some health insurance, I'm lucky to have retiree insurance and now Medicare.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Gigem on November 05, 2023, 03:48:23 PM
With my side business we never did more than 150K a year in revenue up until this last year.  With my kids being older and the company getting more well known we've been able to take on more work and acquired more equipment to be able to take on more work.  I now have at least 3-4 employees of varying skill and ability but nobody who can do it all so I have to try to manage them while I work a regular 40 hr a week job with my wife supervising and helping as best she can.  We've done 400K in revenue so far this year and I'm convinced we will do at least $1MM next year as long as something drastic doesn't happen to the economy.  For our area, it seems like the recessions and slowdowns of the past never really hit our area and we just keep growing.  

I've never really taken a straight salary or paycheck, always put the money back in the business and lived off my regular job paycheck.  But I feel now that we are reaching critical mass that maybe (probably) the one missing ingredient to be profitable will be for me to do this full time.  Right now it's tough on me because I'm taking vacation days to go work at my business, working after hours and most weekends trying to keep things running but I know I can't do this forever.  

Which brings me back to the topic at hand...what am I working for?  If I stay two more years I'm still going to have the same meager pension and lousy health benefits.  I can start my own 401K from my company for myself and contribute more than my old job would.  I can get my own health insurance and let the company pay for it.  

I know we have some other entrepreneurs on here, I'd like to hear your thoughts as well as the thoughts of other people who know their retirement benefits ain't all that.  
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Gigem on November 05, 2023, 03:50:48 PM
I hit a wall about then in my career.  I basically started mailing it in, I did what was necessary, not an iota more, for probably 15 years.  It was a "hunker down" situation for me, I had three kids to put through college etc.  I despised work, and many of my coworkers (some were OK).  When 2008 hit, I figured I'd have to work another 5 years over my "plan" to make up for it, but things came back quicker than I thought.

Before that, I felt like I had a "career" with some incentives for working, after that, it was just work.  I couldn't quit, I couldn't find another job, I was just stuck.

In 2013 they came out with retirement packages for folks at my level, but excluded those of us on the technical side of things as we were "too valuable".  I was PO'd.  My buddy told me to stick around and it would happen for us, and it did six months later.  I was glad to be done of it.  I should write a book.

P.S.  Every year you work is a year you don't have to "cover" with your retirement.  And you'll likely need some health insurance, I'm lucky to have retiree insurance and now Medicare.
I'm not going to stop working, I'd just spend more time building my company.  As I stated, my health insurance will be expensive, even with a high deductible plan.  $1200 a month, and will 100% increase every year but my pension/benefits will not.  
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Gigem on November 05, 2023, 03:57:12 PM
One more thing that factors into this for me is that most of the people who I know that have retired recently have all taken post-retirement jobs.  Some of them didn't need the money, some did, hardly nobody I know really retires anymore like they did in the 80's and 90's.  Seems like most people retire in their late 50's/early 60's, get another job and work until they are eligible for Medicare and SS.  I don't really need a lot of money to live, I have no other debt except for what I have in this business.  
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Honestbuckeye on November 05, 2023, 04:15:17 PM
First nice job getting yourself into a place where you have the option!

Based on what you have set aside, what you can can do with your side business, and the perception I get of which makes you happy- go for it.  The day you can get out of corporate America is a day you win!
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Gigem on November 05, 2023, 04:17:30 PM
Thanks for the encouragement.  Right now I'm leaning towards retiring early and putting all my energy and time into my business.  

How does your retirement situation look?  
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: LittlePig on November 05, 2023, 04:31:29 PM
I am about ready to pull the plug myself.  I just turned 57.  My spreadsheet says work until I am 60 but emotionally I am done.  Sometimes like you said you have to suck it up and sometimes you don't.  When you know you don't have to suck it up anymore,  it's hard to find the motivation to keep coming in,  even if you know you could get away with mailing it in.

I will probably have to do some part time contract work to supplement my retirement income,  but even if I never work again, I will survive.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: huskerdinie on November 05, 2023, 04:43:32 PM
I spent most of my working in low level jobs with no retirement plans provided by my employer.  I did work for the state for 5 years and had some "retirement" saved but had to use that for moving expenses, so right back where I started.  I ended my working life as a shift manager at McDonald's so diddly squat for retirement there - I left at 62 due to being unable to stand for 8 hours a day after breaking my leg at work - did not qualify for disability, and ended up taking Social Security earlier than planned.  Hubby lost his job during the pandemic and has not been able to return to work due to shoulder issues (worked hard labor jobs his entire life).  

So we live off of my Social Security, and Medicaid for his insurance and Medicare/Medicaid for mine.  Luckily, we own our home and get a homestead exemption for property taxes, but we never had any savings to rely on.  We have just hunkered down and have my sister and youngest son living with us to help with Lot rent for our mobile home (which just got raised another $75/mo!)  It sucks to work at a job you are not happy with, but I now wish I had stayed working for the state; I would have been better off.  

I never was good at financial planning/retirement planning, etc.  Used my inheritance from my parents (along with my sister's) to buy our mobile home and a reliable car (that got stolen this summer, lol).  I will be 70 next year, my husband will be 60, so we have a few more years of hanging in until he gets his Social Security.  

I feel for you; it is not easy to work in this day and age and have to juggle priorities for your future retirement; most people I know did have to go back to work part time after retirement just to make ends meet, but it sucks to have to stay in a job that is not what you want it to.  

Sorry about the rambling; I hope it all works out for you in the future - Good luck!  
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: utee94 on November 05, 2023, 05:13:05 PM
I don't mind corporate America.  It's been good to me.

I did my time working for a small startup during the initial Dot Com boom.  It was an interesting adventure, I'm glad I did it, but my startup was part of the 99% of those businesses that failed instead of "making it."  

I did make some fortunate moves and invested in real estate, keeping our first home and turning it into a rental, and then buying my way into a couple more rental units.  It resulted in some super lean years when we bought our new home without any money coming from the sale of the prior home, but we managed it and I'm glad we did it.

I now have a great work-life balance with a super-flexible job at an employer where I need to map out another ten years of career moves, and that should be very do-able.  I'm there for my kids, I'm there for my wife, and I'm there for my parents who aren't getting any younger or healthier.

Ten years from now the kids are done with college and I'm trading the way-too-big suburban house for some remote property, and a Class A motorhome.  I'll let you all know when I'm near you, and I'll buy you a beer when I see you.

Or maybe I move to tiny beachfront town somewhere in the Caribbean. That would do, too.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: MaximumSam on November 05, 2023, 05:27:39 PM
I also think doing it makes a lot of sense. You have a pension and a substantial amount of money in retirement if things go sideways on your business that can bridge you until you get a new job. But your business is doing well, you are happier doing it, and you could potentially make substantially more money doing it. Feels like a no brainer to me.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: OrangeAfroMan on November 05, 2023, 05:52:24 PM
I can retire at 53, but if I wait until 55, I get a lot more payout per month.

I'm 43 and am disenfranchised by one political party attempting to disband public education.  It's not fun to give full effort towards something, only to be undercut by decision-makers who's kids never attended a public school. 

I'm exhausted with giving my all to help broken children from broken homes in impoverished neighborhoods.  They would all be fine if we didn't have to send them home each afternoon.

I'm actually looking elsewhere - jobs that would keep adding to my retirement while no longer being in the classroom.  District jobs are few and far between.  I could try the AZ Dept of Education, but I'd be in the lion's den, so to speak.  I'd literally have to watch what I said, a la living in Tehran or something.  I may also look into jobs at ASU. 

I may just need a 1-year breather.  The idea of showing up and being a productive worker bee in a quiet environment sounds amazing right now.

Idk. 

I'd honestly just rather have had to build my own cabin and hunt/grow food for myself out in nature.  Our "civilized" society kind of sucks, imo.  With all of our advancements, the only 3 things I actually value and "need" are air conditioning, hot showers, and the internet. 
You can keep all the rest of it.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Gigem on November 05, 2023, 06:02:24 PM
I don't mind corporate America.  It's been good to me.

I did my time working for a small startup during the initial Dot Com boom.  It was an interesting adventure, I'm glad I did it, but my startup was part of the 99% of those businesses that failed instead of "making it." 

I did make some fortunate moves and invested in real estate, keeping our first home and turning it into a rental, and then buying my way into a couple more rental units.  It resulted in some super lean years when we bought our new home without any money coming from the sale of the prior home, but we managed it and I'm glad we did it.

I now have a great work-life balance with a super-flexible job at an employer where I need to map out another ten years of career moves, and that should be very do-able.  I'm there for my kids, I'm there for my wife, and I'm there for my parents who aren't getting any younger or healthier.

Ten years from now the kids are done with college and I'm trading the way-too-big suburban house for some remote property, and a Class A motorhome.  I'll let you all know when I'm near you, and I'll buy you a beer when I see you.

Or maybe I move to tiny beachfront town somewhere in the Caribbean. That would do, too.
I also own rental real estate and my wife manages it (no super expensive properties, just a bunch of small to medium ones).  Not enough to live on, but enough to help pay for stuff if needed.  

I really don't mind my corporate life, and I am now blessed to have a good work-life balance.  My job is OK, I don't despise going to work but just like everybody else sometimes I get tired of updating spreadsheets and making sure the TPS report is tidied up.  

But what I'm really asking about is what kind of benefits do you have in retirement?  I looked at mine, and while I do have some, they're not great.  So I really am not sure what I'm staying for.  I always thought I'd retire in my mid to late 50's, but even if I stayed and did that I don't think the benefits would be all that great.  #1 is health insurance until I make it to Medicare.  
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: utee94 on November 05, 2023, 06:22:18 PM
I also own rental real estate and my wife manages it (no super expensive properties, just a bunch of small to medium ones).  Not enough to live on, but enough to help pay for stuff if needed. 

I really don't mind my corporate life, and I am now blessed to have a good work-life balance.  My job is OK, I don't despise going to work but just like everybody else sometimes I get tired of updating spreadsheets and making sure the TPS report is tidied up. 

But what I'm really asking about is what kind of benefits do you have in retirement?  I looked at mine, and while I do have some, they're not great.  So I really am not sure what I'm staying for.  I always thought I'd retire in my mid to late 50's, but even if I stayed and did that I don't think the benefits would be all that great.  #1 is health insurance until I make it to Medicare. 

Retirement benefits?  Not sure what that even means. :)

Pensions were long gone in my field well before I entered the work force.  Our 401K has a decent company match, that's all I got, aside from what I do on my own.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Honestbuckeye on November 05, 2023, 06:53:59 PM
Oh, don’t get me wrong. Corporate America has been good to me as well and I have been fortunate to be surrounded by really good people.

Unfortunately, in the financial industry, the concept of pensions died back in the 80s and 90s.  

I am older than you ( 62) and have been in the industry for 37 years (since 86). So I have been saving for retirement for a long time. And invested conservatively while living through the ups and downs of the market. 

To your question- how am I situated. 

The bad news is there are virtually no benefits other than my 401K which is in decent shape- but no health or medical etc. 

The good news is- I could pull the trigger right now and live comfortably ( no where near current income level). But because I have paid off my house and have no real debt, we would be fine.  Kids are grown and fully financially independent. 

But I currently have a pretty good work life balance because since the pandemic I’ve been working from home, and I am lucky to be in a more strategic job. My value is my experience and it’s kind of fun using that every day to help people get things done and get better at what they do. so I’ll probably keep doing it for another year or two 

Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: MaximumSam on November 05, 2023, 07:58:21 PM

Quote
But what I'm really asking about is what kind of benefits do you have in retirement? 
I work for the state and have a pension. It has reduced payouts for early retirement, which means I'm probably not thinking about it for another 15 years or so. 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: OrangeAfroMan on November 05, 2023, 08:11:34 PM
The penalty for cashing out our retirement early is substantial.  As in you'd get like 25% of the actual money that's sitting in it at the moment. 
I understand some penalty, but jesus christ.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: ELA on November 05, 2023, 10:27:00 PM
I assumed every Texas A&M alum was just working to pay the NIL of an overrated 5* recruit or the buyout of a coach just mailing it in for a paycheck :57:
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: ELA on November 05, 2023, 10:32:33 PM
But, seriously, I don't know.  I'm 39, with 3 kids.  We have been saving for college since the first one, who is now 10 and 1/2, was born, and we could maybe pay for one year of college for one of them. The thought of retirement is comical
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on November 06, 2023, 07:59:22 AM
I think it's useful to have a realistic retirement goal, taking inflation into consideration.  A good first step, usually, is to pay off any debt.  Your house can serve as a retirement asset if it's paid off or nearly so.  If you pay off a car loan, start putting $150 or so each month into a "car account" so you pay off the next one ahead of time.  And I realize for anyone living close to the edge this isn't practicable advice.  I've been there.

A reason I took the job I did was their retirement plan.  It was generous, not a pension, but the company bought stock (in the company) for us each year.  I knew secretaries who worked there 30 years who had well over a million, which was real money back then.  A problem with state pensions can be that the pensions are in deep water (Illinois) and won't be able to pay much in the future, Social Security is in the same boat to an extent.  But even if not fixed, SS would be able to pay about 75% of current benefits, so I don't view it as "I'll never see a dime" kind of thing (I am on it now.).

It's useful not to consider SS until you start getting it though.  And of course the amount you get is based on 35 years of salary where you paid FICA.  
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: OrangeAfroMan on November 06, 2023, 08:18:56 AM
I didn't know state workers don't get SS.  Found that out about 6 months ago.
Would have been nice to know 20 years ago.  

We'll teach you calculus and French literature, but nothing about how to navigate the actual real life society you'll enter into.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on November 06, 2023, 08:21:23 AM
How State and Local Government Employees are Covered by Social Security and Medicare (ssa.gov) (https://www.ssa.gov/pubs/EN-05-10051.pdf)

At one time, Social Security didn’t include any of these employees. Over the years, the law changed. Most employees have Social Security protection, because their states have special agreements with us called “Section 218 agreements.” Congress passed a law in July 1991 extending Social Security on a mandatory basis to most state and local employees. These are employees not covered by an agreement or a Social Security equivalent public pension system. 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: MrNubbz on November 06, 2023, 08:25:15 AM
The penalty for cashing out our retirement early is substantial.  As in you'd get like 25% of the actual money that's sitting in it at the moment. 
I understand some penalty, but jesus christ.
Get deferred payments for sure rather than one lump sum. The assholes could at least have the common decency of waving a gun in your face 1st before takiing a 1/3 rd
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on November 06, 2023, 08:45:42 AM
I didn't know state workers don't get SS.  Found that out about 6 months ago.
Where did you hear this?  Do you a line that says FICA in your pacycheck stub?
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on November 06, 2023, 08:49:10 AM
State and Local Government Employees Without Social Security Coverage: What Percentage Will Earn Pension Benefits That Fall Short of Social Security Equivalence? (ssa.gov) (https://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/ssb/v82n3/v82n3p1.html)

Apparently, if you get a state pension, you may not be covered by SS.  

Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: FearlessF on November 06, 2023, 09:01:32 AM
healthcare.gov
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: MrNubbz on November 06, 2023, 09:06:43 AM
State and Local Government Employees Without Social Security Coverage: What Percentage Will Earn Pension Benefits That Fall Short of Social Security Equivalence? (ssa.gov) (https://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/ssb/v82n3/v82n3p1.html)

Apparently, if you get a state pension, you may not be covered by SS



YUP that is a fact
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Gigem on November 06, 2023, 09:07:27 AM
I didn't know state workers don't get SS.  Found that out about 6 months ago.
Would have been nice to know 20 years ago. 

We'll teach you calculus and French literature, but nothing about how to navigate the actual real life society you'll enter into.
Question for you, and I'm not trying to be an asshole.  Did you pay the FICA taxes?  

I'm always confused on how select gov't employees don't have to pay SS tax, even when they're not federal employees.  We have school districts here in Tx that opt in and some that opt out.  

There was a big loophole a few years ago that if a spouse never worked they could get spousal SS benefits if their spouse died but if they worked as a teacher they could not get it.  So a few retired teachers went to a district, paid them a fee, and worked for like two weeks or something and they could get the benefit.  The gov't closed the loophole.  
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on November 06, 2023, 09:11:42 AM
The links I posted outline this story pretty well though it's confusing.  Basically, a state pension in many cases is used in place of any SS benefit.  They don't pay FICA, they don't get the benefit, so it's basically an even proposition, or should be.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Gigem on November 06, 2023, 09:12:59 AM
The main issue I have with it is that only gov't entities can opt out.  
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on November 06, 2023, 09:21:07 AM
Sure, I suspect we'd all be better off without FICA and SS, especially badger.  I just figured I paid FICA taxes to support SS for folks getting the benefit then like my parents.

It's a weird system, really, but enormously popular of course, third rail and all that.

And neither Congress nor any President seems willing to fix it.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Gigem on November 06, 2023, 09:26:36 AM
I actually have no issues with SS as a whole.  I don't think congress should be allowed to raid the fund and replace it with IOU's.  

Obviously it has needed tweaked here and there, but overall I think it's been a very good thing for America.  
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on November 06, 2023, 09:38:06 AM
I actually have no issues with SS as a whole.  I don't think congress should be allowed to raid the fund and replace it with IOU's. 
The SS Trust Fund has to be invested in something.  I can't think of a better option than special Treasury bonds.  

Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on November 06, 2023, 12:51:57 PM
One major thing about aging is finding physical maladies for which you have no explanation.  I somehow wrenched my left wrist a week or so ago, I have no clue what I did or when I did it.  It's just annoying, not really painful except with certain movements.  I usually do some pushups daily and I can't now.  My wife may ask about a bruise and I see it and have no idea how it happened.

The best decision we made I think was to move somewhere where walking is easy and interesting.  We try and walk daily, I usually run some as well.  It's pretty easy to retire and veg out.

As for the money aspects, that is a much tougher equation at 50 than 60 or 65.  But then working yourself until you are depressed isn't good either.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: SuperMario on November 06, 2023, 03:52:43 PM
If I was in your shoes, the one thing that would dictate my decision would be medical benefits/coverage.  I'm possibly biased there and in the past I would have solely said "bet on yourself," but my family and I went through a lot the last 12 months and my wife's medical benefits kept us afloat. As we get older and medical costs have skyrocketed, having poor coverage when betting on yourself can be destructive if the family isn't fully covered. Luckily, my wife works for the Cleveland Clinic and my $450k surgery only ran us $350 out of pocket.  So long story short there, look into the medical expense side closely. Not that people will encounter what our family did, but that's an area to prepare for the unknown.

Outside of that. Bet on YOU. You'll be surprised how creative and what we as people are capable of when our backs are against the wall and we have to rely on the well being of ourselves and family when we have to count on ourselves. Creativity and thinking outside of the box blossoms and we are able to reach milestones we never thought possible.  The threat of failure and letting people down we care about, sure can push to reach beyond who we had been in the past.

I had a parent company that I put in 18 years with. The last 5 I ran essentially a setup similar to a franchise beneath their umbrella. The owners I had dinner with 3 times a year with our families. I thought trust was through the roof. When I fell to harsh medical situation and there was the possibility I was done professionally, I was no longer of use to them. They closed up my setup without conversation, without explanation and there's still well into 6 figures "missing" with no explanation from my reserve account with them. I was no longer a benefit to them, they took advantage of what looked like dire medical situation and now I have to have attorneys, doj and other entities involved and it's a mess.

So why share that? Because it pushed my back against the wall and made me bet on myself in a way i didn't think was possible. I still medically wasn't approved to drive yet, yet I found ways to rebuild a business and become incredibly creative. I had 20 people that worked for me in the past stand by my side and help rebuild it and now I don't have to fear shady people that only care about me(you) when you increase the bottom line. It has shifted my mindset to do whatever possible to bet on yourself because businesses rarely actually care about people and they truly only care about $$$$.

If/when you bet on yourself, make the primary focus surrounding yourself with good people. We can never build success solely on our own and having amazing people around you will help reach things over time that seem like a dream. 

Sorry for the long response, but whenever I see someone at this difficult decision in life, I love watching them take such a huge risk and bet on themselves because so often it leads to life changing results. Never easy.. but life changing and i don't want to let fear keep them in a position they never took that chance. No matter what, best of luck with the decision.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Gigem on November 06, 2023, 04:35:33 PM
Posts like this is why I made this topic.  Thank you for sharing your story.  

The medical benefits thing scares me.  But then I think about my friend who sat next to me (we have cubicles, desk thingy's).  He died of cancer last January.  All the best insurance in the world and he lasted 4 months.  

At the same time you realize that even if you work your 30 years (or whatever) the insurance you have until Medicaid kicks in sucks and it's expensive.  

Since you started your own business, how do you handle medical insurance for your employees, if at all?  
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: SuperMario on November 06, 2023, 05:05:22 PM
Posts like this is why I made this topic.  Thank you for sharing your story. 

The medical benefits thing scares me.  But then I think about my friend who sat next to me (we have cubicles, desk thingy's).  He died of cancer last January.  All the best insurance in the world and he lasted 4 months. 

At the same time you realize that even if you work your 30 years (or whatever) the insurance you have until Medicaid kicks in sucks and it's expensive. 

Since you started your own business, how do you handle medical insurance for your employees, if at all? 
Sorry to hear about your friend. The most difficult part of getting older has been losing people or watching people struggle medically that i've been close with. It has lead me to appreciate every day more than I did in the past, but losing good people in life is never easy.

Admittedly, i'm terrible with the knowledge of the medical side so I'll tap into my business partner and send you a message about our medical benefits setup for the rest of your staff. I have not been largely involved in that segment because my kids a I are underneath my wife's coverage, which is amazing coverage. I've had no complaints from our staff on their medical so it must be decent so I'll share when i get some details. 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Riffraft on November 06, 2023, 05:15:01 PM
The wife and I have decided to retire. She just took a buy out at her job and I am waiting till April 20th for some benefits to vest.  She is only 59 and I am 63 so no medicare yet for either of us. 

We have run the numbers and figure we have enought assets to last us the rest of our lives even at our current spending levels.  We hesitated retiring because of the medical insurance, but then her late husband died at 59.  Her brother retired at 70 and died less than 6 months later. 

We figure we are going to travel even more than we already do and make sure we do all the things we want before we can't physically do them (maybe we will always be able to, but why wait if we don't have to).  

There is no guarantee about tomorrow so if you don't have to wait, don't wait. 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Gigem on November 06, 2023, 11:03:30 PM
Your statement on BETTING ON YOU really resonates with me. In fact I have uttered these very words. Because the worst mistake I ever made was trusting someone close, committing resources, time, money, and trust to merge my business with theirs only to be stabbed in the back at the last minute. I gambled and lost because I bet on somebody else. I won’t make that mistake again. 

Shortly after this incident I did in fact make a pretty good bet on myself, I took on some commitments and risks and now I find myself at the crossroads to no surprise. 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on November 07, 2023, 08:19:20 AM
Since you started your own business, how do you handle medical insurance for your employees, if at all? 
I started in late 2000. We offered full medical, dental, eye and life to employees and their families, free of charge to them. We grew to about 20 people pretty quickly. Then 2008 came, and since our business is so closely tied to housing, that was a gut shot. We were at 28 people at the time, and it did not take long for us to trim that to 6. We had no choice.

In the meantime, we transitioned and reinvented the company to include public utility work, schools, park districts, commercial and industrial. This took a while. We still provided full benefits to those we were able to keep.

Things started picking up and we were back to about 20 people by 2010. Still full benefits.

Then the unaffordable care act happened. Our rates about tripled overnight, so we had to cut the family coverage. That was tough to do. Now the employees had to go into their pockets to pay for medical, etc. Still a better rate than they could get on the exchange, of course, and they were able to keep their doctors.

Today, employees pay $25/paycheck for their own coverage, and 100% of what they might need for families.

Had the government stayed out of our hair, we'd still be paying full benefits. We just can't afford to do that anymore.

The moral of the story here is being able to adapt - roll with the punches. There are a lot of punches to take when you own a business, and sometimes you can't see them coming.

I'm winding down now, at 19 percent ownership, as the "kids" we hired back in 2010 buy me out and take over. That's my retirement account - the shares in my company. Thankfully the plan worked. I've made a good living and provided same for a lot of people. That feels good.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on November 07, 2023, 08:29:58 AM
I am reminded a bit of this old geezer at work.  He hit 65 and was at the top rank of the technical ladder.  He was from eastern Europe.  I got to know him a bit, I really didn't think that much of him, his approach was entirely Edisonian.  Anyway, he had to retire at 65, but he kept coming to work.  They let him keep his lab, and he came every day, I'd see him at lunch.  I don't know how long he "worked", but a friend told me he just had no "life" elsewhere.  He would have had a ton of money at his level, millions.

I felt a bit sad for him.  

There was another fellow with office next to mine who was at the same top level, to the point they created another level above that just for him.  He seemed pretty reasonable, we chatted pretty often, it was funny seeing all the young sycophants coming to see him.  He told me he'd come to work as long as they let him.

I understand feeling the "status" at his level, OK fine, but it's work, and that status isn't going to get you anything but some sense of being important.  You're not.  You're a big fish in a small pond at best.

It is great in your career if you did a few things to be proud of of course, employing others is great, getting a business running is great.  The things I'd say I was proud of are all things for which I got zero recognition.  It happens.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Riffraft on November 07, 2023, 09:54:32 AM
I am reminded a bit of this old geezer at work.  He hit 65 and was at the top rank of the technical ladder.  He was from eastern Europe.  I got to know him a bit, I really didn't think that much of him, his approach was entirely Edisonian.  Anyway, he had to retire at 65, but he kept coming to work.  They let him keep his lab, and he came every day, I'd see him at lunch.  I don't know how long he "worked", but a friend told me he just had no "life" elsewhere.  He would have had a ton of money at his level, millions.

I felt a bit sad for him. 

There was another fellow with office next to mine who was at the same top level, to the point they created another level above that just for him.  He seemed pretty reasonable, we chatted pretty often, it was funny seeing all the young sycophants coming to see him.  He told me he'd come to work as long as they let him.

I understand feeling the "status" at his level, OK fine, but it's work, and that status isn't going to get you anything but some sense of being important.  You're not.  You're a big fish in a small pond at best.

It is great in your career if you did a few things to be proud of of course, employing others is great, getting a business running is great.  The things I'd say I was proud of are all things for which I got zero recognition.  It happens.
Goes to the old adage, do you live to work or work to live?  Personally I work to live.  Work has always been a means to an end. Provide for my family.  Allow me to do the things I want to do.  Give generously to causes and organization I support.  Now that I don't need to work anymore to live, I gladly put it away and move on. 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: FearlessF on November 07, 2023, 10:05:20 AM
I worked to live until a couple years ago
Now I live to work
enjoying my job
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: MikeDeTiger on November 07, 2023, 11:44:35 AM
I don't mean this in a nosy way, but out of genuine curosity....you guys who started/own your own businesses, if you don't mind getting into it....what are they, specifically? 

I'm always curious to find out what needs people saw and what business they started in order to fill it, how they structured it, etc.  
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on November 07, 2023, 11:47:09 AM
I know badger pretends to be an engineer, but in reality, he digs ditches.  And builds dikes.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on November 07, 2023, 01:06:28 PM
How much to save monthly on $80,000/year to retire with $1.5 million (cnbc.com) (https://www.cnbc.com/2023/11/07/how-much-to-save-monthly-on-80000-dollars-per-year-to-retire-with-1point5-million.html)

If you start at 25


You can see the impact of RoR on the numbers.  Presuming this is in some tax deferred account, you still have inflation to worry about.  That $1.5 mil might sound pretty good now and look paltry in 30 years.  A 5% R0R might end up being 0% after inflation, and you'd still be paying taxes on withdrawals.


Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: medinabuckeye1 on November 07, 2023, 01:21:37 PM
P.S.  Every year you work is a year you don't have to "cover" with your retirement.  And you'll likely need some health insurance, I'm lucky to have retiree insurance and now Medicare.
I do generally think that "betting on you" as others have put it is probably a good idea and worth at least seriously considering but, being the resident accountant/pessimist I'll give some devil's advocate thoughts.  I'm doing this largely because a lot of people have already said "go for it" so me being another one of those wouldn't really help you so I'll take the opposite side.  

The item I quoted from @Cincydawg (https://www.cfb51.com/index.php?action=profile;u=870) is an important consideration.  You are my age (late 40's) so you have ~30 years to the average life expectancy.  IIRC you said your 401k had around $1/2 Million.  If you can add $33k/yr and you stay three more years you get to $600k plus you have three less years to cover.  
Math:
That is WAY oversimplified as it doesn't account for investment returns either while you are working or after you are retired but what I am illustrating here is that three extra years can make a VERY substantial difference.  

A second consideration:
How cyclical is your business?  Badge mentioned being heavily involved in housing and having to trim his company from 28 employees to 6.  Housing is hyper-cyclical because it can more-or-less always be deferred so in a recession it tends to plummet.  OTOH, if you are selling low-cost food that tends not to be cyclical at all because everybody has to eat.  Some businesses are even counter-cyclical as demand grows for lower-cost items when recession worries peak.  

Personally, I think we are headed for at least a slow-down.  That said, there is an old joke that most economists have predicted 5 out of the last 3 recessions because they always tend to predict recessions, LoL.  

I didn't predict the 2020 Pandemic.  I didn't predict the 2008 credit crunch/recession.  I didn't predict the early-2000's dot-com bubble burst.  Thus, I'm not going to pretend that I can predict the next calamity.  That said, I can predict with absolute certainty that there WILL BE a calamity.  It might be just a garden-variety recession or it might be some weird credit-thing or it might be some weird pandemic but whatever it is, there WILL BE a calamity.  

If your business is hyper-cyclical, I wouldn't want to depend on it until I got to the point where I could comfortably live without it.  

A third consideration:
How hard would it be to get back into employment if your side business went sideways?  You mentioned making low $100's and considering that to be bad.  You also said you don't have a degree.  That is fine if you are a certified underwater basketweaver or whatever and your profession is in demand and you could either stay certified or easily get recertified and return to that line of work if you had to.  If not, the salary for non-degreed labor around here is nowhere close to $100k.  If you had to jump back in, where would you realistically be jumping in?  

I don't have a lot of faith in SS and frankly, at our age I don't consider $500k to be anywhere close to enough to live on for the rest of our lives.  Assuming a 10% return and 30 years of remaining lifespan that $500k is enough to get you around $53k/yr.  Is that enough for you to live on?  Furthermore, that rate may be optimistic and even if you hit it, you'd be flat broke at 78.  If you stretch that out to 40 years the annual drops to $51k, is that enough?  If you stretch it out to 40 years and think you need $100k, you need almost $1M.  

At this point in your life and using my 10% assumed return, you need to add $2,763,26 to add one more year to your retirement "coverage".  So if you work one more year and put $2,763.26 in your account, you are effectively adding two years.  (That relationship isn't linear just FYI).  

Just food for thought and I'm (mostly) just playing devil's advocate.  

Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: betarhoalphadelta on November 07, 2023, 01:45:01 PM
You are my age (late 40's) so you have ~30 years to the average life expectancy.    

Just one point here. The average life expectancy of 78 is from birth. The average life expectancy for a male who reaches age 65 is another 18 years, or 83:

https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/factsheets/factsheet_nvss.pdf

The life expectancy from birth takes into account infant mortality, accidental/criminal deaths, and all sorts of other things that might lead to lower lifespan. But given that the goal is saving for retirement, the idea should be to plan for at or beyond the life expectancy at age 65. 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Gigem on November 07, 2023, 01:57:27 PM
So there is a fundamental misunderstanding of the purpose of this thread by a couple of people.  I'm not looking to retire and NOT work.  I'm looking to leave my current job/career early to pursue ramping up my business.  

The question I'm asking or pondering is "What am I staying for?".  In other words, what do I lose by leaving a few years early.  

I really should have known some of this but when I hired in in my 20's but retirement seemed a long way away and my company was known at the time for having good retirement benefits.  And the benefits are confusing, because if you hired in at such and such date and this and that you get this and that, so it's not really clear.

Plus, they changed the game for retirees, three times now.  And that's just three times since I've been here.  They changed it in the 80's and 90's, as I'm sure all companies do, but it makes it cloudy to determine exactly where I land but I'm starting to get a better picture.  

So far here is what I have found:
-Medical benefits suck.  You have to be at least 50 to even get retirement insurance, and it's expensive ($850-$1200 depending on YOS).  It's also a high deductible plan.  Not sure at this point if I couldn't do better on my own.  

-Pension.  This one is easy.  No more pension after this year, no matter how many more years I work.  I only have what I've already put in it.  The only difference I can see is that there is an option that you can get more money from the day you start drawing until you receive SS but only if you retire at 50 or older.  So if I leave now I won't get it.  The downside is that once SS kicks in the pension goes way down.  Not sure if this one is worth waiting on, I need to model it a little more.  

-401K.  I already know how much I have in it.  The match goes up starting next year to defer some of the loss of the pension.  Not a bad deal because it definitely does not tie you to a company, and when you're done, you're really done.  I think I can start my own 401K via my company and roll my current one into it, and maybe even put as much or more money into it than what I would get if I stay.  But only if we make enough money (profit) to get to that point.  
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: betarhoalphadelta on November 07, 2023, 01:59:23 PM
It is great in your career if you did a few things to be proud of of course

The things I'd say I was proud of are all things for which I got zero recognition.
Oddly enough, this document (https://documents.westerndigital.com/content/dam/doc-library/en_us/assets/public/western-digital/collateral/white-paper/white-paper-ssd-endurance-and-hdd-workloads.pdf) is one of the things I'm most proud of since switching to my new role. It came out of a blogger/review site reviewing one of our products and making it clear that he didn't understand anything about certain specifications common in our industry and what they meant. I looked around at anything we'd produced, anything our competitors had produced, and realized there wasn't a single document available in our entire industry that could adequately explain the relationship. So I wrote it. 

It isn't some document about our products specifically... It applies to the entire industry. It's a bit boring and technical. But nothing like it existed before, so I feel like I contributed something to world knowledge on the subject by producing it, and explained things in a way that you don't have to be knee deep in storage device reliability as your career to understand it.

It's not a big thing... But it's mine. 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: medinabuckeye1 on November 07, 2023, 02:26:16 PM
Just one point here. The average life expectancy of 78 is from birth. The average life expectancy for a male who reaches age 65 is another 18 years, or 83:

https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/factsheets/factsheet_nvss.pdf

The life expectancy from birth takes into account infant mortality, accidental/criminal deaths, and all sorts of other things that might lead to lower lifespan. But given that the goal is saving for retirement, the idea should be to plan for at or beyond the life expectancy at age 65.
You are right. I actually pulled up that document before I did my post but thought it would overcomplicate it so I left it out.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Gigem on November 07, 2023, 02:34:10 PM
I do generally think that "betting on you" as others have put it is probably a good idea and worth at least seriously considering but, being the resident accountant/pessimist I'll give some devil's advocate thoughts.  I'm doing this largely because a lot of people have already said "go for it" so me being another one of those wouldn't really help you so I'll take the opposite side. 

The item I quoted from @Cincydawg (https://www.cfb51.com/index.php?action=profile;u=870) is an important consideration.  You are my age (late 40's) so you have ~30 years to the average life expectancy.  IIRC you said your 401k had around $1/2 Million.  If you can add $33k/yr and you stay three more years you get to $600k plus you have three less years to cover. 
Math:
  • $500k/30 = $16,667/yr
  • $600k/27 = $22,222/yr
  • $5,555/yr difference 33%
That is WAY oversimplified as it doesn't account for investment returns either while you are working or after you are retired but what I am illustrating here is that three extra years can make a VERY substantial difference. 

A second consideration:
How cyclical is your business?  Badge mentioned being heavily involved in housing and having to trim his company from 28 employees to 6.  Housing is hyper-cyclical because it can more-or-less always be deferred so in a recession it tends to plummet.  OTOH, if you are selling low-cost food that tends not to be cyclical at all because everybody has to eat.  Some businesses are even counter-cyclical as demand grows for lower-cost items when recession worries peak. 

Personally, I think we are headed for at least a slow-down.  That said, there is an old joke that most economists have predicted 5 out of the last 3 recessions because they always tend to predict recessions, LoL. 

I didn't predict the 2020 Pandemic.  I didn't predict the 2008 credit crunch/recession.  I didn't predict the early-2000's dot-com bubble burst.  Thus, I'm not going to pretend that I can predict the next calamity.  That said, I can predict with absolute certainty that there WILL BE a calamity.  It might be just a garden-variety recession or it might be some weird credit-thing or it might be some weird pandemic but whatever it is, there WILL BE a calamity. 

If your business is hyper-cyclical, I wouldn't want to depend on it until I got to the point where I could comfortably live without it. 

A third consideration:
How hard would it be to get back into employment if your side business went sideways?  You mentioned making low $100's and considering that to be bad.  You also said you don't have a degree.  That is fine if you are a certified underwater basketweaver or whatever and your profession is in demand and you could either stay certified or easily get recertified and return to that line of work if you had to.  If not, the salary for non-degreed labor around here is nowhere close to $100k.  If you had to jump back in, where would you realistically be jumping in? 

I don't have a lot of faith in SS and frankly, at our age I don't consider $500k to be anywhere close to enough to live on for the rest of our lives.  Assuming a 10% return and 30 years of remaining lifespan that $500k is enough to get you around $53k/yr.  Is that enough for you to live on?  Furthermore, that rate may be optimistic and even if you hit it, you'd be flat broke at 78.  If you stretch that out to 40 years the annual drops to $51k, is that enough?  If you stretch it out to 40 years and think you need $100k, you need almost $1M. 

At this point in your life and using my 10% assumed return, you need to add $2,763,26 to add one more year to your retirement "coverage".  So if you work one more year and put $2,763.26 in your account, you are effectively adding two years.  (That relationship isn't linear just FYI). 

Just food for thought and I'm (mostly) just playing devil's advocate. 
Couple of points: 

-I do have my degree.  But I've mostly worked jobs that didn't really *require* having a degree, or not exactly the degree I have.  The job I have now is the closest I've had to needing a degree, but about half the people in my job do have one and half don't.  

-I think I could probably go back to work for my old company fairly easily, either as a direct hire or a contractor.  It's very common for people to come and go, and they often seek out former employees of good standing for special projects/assignments.  Very common for retirees to come back after a year or two off.  I've actually applied for other jobs at other companies through the years in times of being disgruntled and gotten interviews fairly easily, but never offered a job.  

- Business is somewhat cyclical, and tied to housing, but our area was, is, and projected to be high growth for decades.  Every time we turn around they're announcing another billion dollar project in our back yard, more jobs, and high paying jobs relative to other parts of the country.  It also seems that we still have a LCOL compared to other places and robust demand for housing even when the rest of the country is depressed.  
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: betarhoalphadelta on November 07, 2023, 02:49:03 PM
@Gigem (https://www.cfb51.com/index.php?action=profile;u=1706) It seems to me that there might be tangible benefits to hanging on 2 more years to hit age 50. As you mention you'll have to model it more and consider the opportunity cost of what you would forego building your business during that time. 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Gigem on November 07, 2023, 03:05:18 PM
I wanted to add that I don't really think that making low $100's sucks, but with a one income family it's not that much money.  It's definitely a good living, but not a great one and I think I can just do better with my own business and I don't want to wait until I'm in my 50's to really kick this thing off.  

As far as waiting until I'm 50 I'm struggling because I'm juggling both.  Not sure I can do this for two more years, I don't have anybody who can replace me even if I had enough money to pay somebody.  This field/business is specialized knowledge, most of the people who have this knowledge already have their own business.  
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: medinabuckeye1 on November 07, 2023, 04:23:58 PM
Just one point here. The average life expectancy of 78 is from birth. The average life expectancy for a male who reaches age 65 is another 18 years, or 83:

https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/factsheets/factsheet_nvss.pdf

The life expectancy from birth takes into account infant mortality, accidental/criminal deaths, and all sorts of other things that might lead to lower lifespan. But given that the goal is saving for retirement, the idea should be to plan for at or beyond the life expectancy at age 65.
More on life expectancy:
Total aside, the SSA's newest numbers have male life expectancy at birth down to just over 74 years which is a SUBSTANTIAL drop from around 78 years not long ago.  

Anyway, they have a handy-dandy life expectancy table that lists not just life expectancy at birth and life expectancy at 65 but life expectancy at every age up to well past 100.  

As @betarhoalphadelta (https://www.cfb51.com/index.php?action=profile;u=19) pointed out, it increases as you age.  Ie, as each year passes your expected remaining lifespan decreases but it decreases by less than one year.  Per the latest table:

Now for the more relevant considerations:
The problem, for retirement calculations, is that being wrong is highly problematic.  Ie, if @Gigem (https://www.cfb51.com/index.php?action=profile;u=1706) plans his retirement to get him to exactly 78 because that is SSA's average life expectancy for him at 48 and he does live to 78, he'll be flat broke and still expected to live another nine years.  

If you are running a large pension or annuity system this isn't a major problem because some people will die young and some will live for a long time and it all balances out.  The pension/annuity provider effectively takes some of the money from the people who died young and gives it to the people with higher longevity.  

However, if you are planning your own retirement you don't have a "balance out".  If you live longer than your savings you just plain run out of money.  One way to adjust for this is to add the extra longevity each year.  Ie:
At first this is almost no difference.  The problem is that the longer you live the bigger the recalibrations become.  

Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: medinabuckeye1 on November 07, 2023, 04:26:47 PM
I wanted to add that I don't really think that making low $100's sucks, but with a one income family it's not that much money.  It's definitely a good living, but not a great one and I think I can just do better with my own business and I don't want to wait until I'm in my 50's to really kick this thing off. 
I get that.  When I was in college I thought $100k/yr was a TON of money.  It really was a lot more then than it is now but the other difference is that I'm not a single guy with no kids anymore.  For a single guy with no kids, $100k can pay rent, make the payments on a cool car, and buy a LOT of beer.  

When you are married with kids $100k isn't so much money anymore.  
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: MaximumSam on November 07, 2023, 06:09:27 PM

Quote
So there is a fundamental misunderstanding of the purpose of this thread by a couple of people.  I'm not looking to retire and NOT work.  I'm looking to leave my current job/career early to pursue ramping up my business.  
I just think the basic math suggests leaving is good. The pension can't get higher and will cover your health insurance and probably whatever 401K match they are doing. So it's really just whether you can live based on your business, and you suggested earlier I think as much as a 500K increase in revenue if you are doing it full time, which far outstrips your current salary. But even if you are wrong and growth is only 100K, you are still even. And if it goes sideways you can likely get your job back. Am I missing something? Seem like a pretty easy decision.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: betarhoalphadelta on November 07, 2023, 07:17:56 PM
I just think the basic math suggests leaving is good. The pension can't get higher and will cover your health insurance and probably whatever 401K match they are doing. So it's really just whether you can live based on your business, and you suggested earlier I think as much as a 500K increase in revenue if you are doing it full time, which far outstrips your current salary. But even if you are wrong and growth is only 100K, you are still even. And if it goes sideways you can likely get your job back. Am I missing something? Seem like a pretty easy decision.

A 500K increase in revenue doesn't help if it results in a 480K increase in costs...
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Gigem on November 07, 2023, 07:18:21 PM
I figure I’d need to hit about $750k in revenue to equal my current salary, assuming a 20% profit rate, which imo is a little high. Probably closer to 12-15% is more realistic. We’re close to 500k in revenue for the year but we ramped up our business starting in June. Before June we only took smaller, lower paying jobs. 

I’m fairly confident we can hit $1 MM in revenue next year assuming I’m full time. 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Gigem on November 07, 2023, 07:20:16 PM
A 500K increase in revenue doesn't help if it results in a 480K increase in costs...
BART has it right. As we’ve increased our revenue our costs go up in unison. Which is why I need to be more involved in daily ops. 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: MaximumSam on November 07, 2023, 08:53:00 PM
A 500K increase in revenue doesn't help if it results in a 480K increase in costs...
Well that's not the healthiest margin to quit your job over
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: betarhoalphadelta on November 07, 2023, 09:08:37 PM
BART has it right. As we’ve increased our revenue our costs go up in unison. Which is why I need to be more involved in daily ops.
beta rho alpha delta = Brad
Bart = beta alpha rho tau
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: MaximumSam on November 07, 2023, 09:13:40 PM
beta rho alpha delta = Brad
Bart = beta alpha rho tau

Thanks Bart
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on November 08, 2023, 06:38:24 AM
Thanks Bert.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on November 08, 2023, 06:38:57 AM
I don't mean this in a nosy way, but out of genuine curosity....you guys who started/own your own businesses, if you don't mind getting into it....what are they, specifically? 

I'm always curious to find out what needs people saw and what business they started in order to fill it, how they structured it, etc. 
Civil Engineering - Land Surveying - Land Planning
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on November 08, 2023, 06:39:47 AM
Some guy named Bert did it.

Inflation is your enemy.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Gigem on November 09, 2023, 11:23:36 AM
beta rho alpha delta = Brad
Bart = beta alpha rho tau
My apologies Brad.  When I see your name my brain spells out Bart first, or Bert.  
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: OrangeAfroMan on November 09, 2023, 06:40:24 PM
My side business is portions of pennies on the dollar of these other guys.
Drew has made it a reality with the website upkeep and what-not.  Hopefully, we'll be creating a good football game field apparatus that will sell well by itself.

I average about $10K gross and net $7500-8000 per year.

https://whoanelliecollegefootball.com/ (https://whoanelliecollegefootball.com/)

I'd have to "bet on myself" to increase that.  I'm capped out as doing it on the side while teaching full-time. 
If I had time and an employee, I could expand it quite a bit, but no idea how much. 

The plus of keeping it small and on the side is I don't NEED a penny of the income and there is no pressure.
The plus of expanding it would be unknown additional monies, BUT pressure and risk.

Peanuts, for now and for the foreseeable future.

Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: betarhoalphadelta on November 09, 2023, 07:15:40 PM
My side business is portions of pennies on the dollar of these other guys.
Drew has made it a reality with the website upkeep and what-not.  Hopefully, we'll be creating a good football game field apparatus that will sell well by itself.

I average about $10K gross and net $7500-8000 per year.

https://whoanelliecollegefootball.com/ (https://whoanelliecollegefootball.com/)

I'd have to "bet on myself" to increase that.  I'm capped out as doing it on the side while teaching full-time. 
If I had time and an employee, I could expand it quite a bit, but no idea how much. 

The plus of keeping it small and on the side is I don't NEED a penny of the income and there is no pressure.
The plus of expanding it would be unknown additional monies, BUT pressure and risk.

Peanuts, for now and for the foreseeable future.


Question: what do you think is your limit on growth? Potential market size, or lack of customer knowledge that your product exists? 

I don't know anything about the tabletop gaming market. Obviously we all know a little something about the hardcore CFB fan market. But I don't know how bit the Venn Diagram intersection of those two are... So consider all of the rest of this pure speculation...

My gut feeling is that your TAM (total addressable market) is very small. And probably not sustainable--if you exhaust that market, you might have a little bit of a longer-term business of expansion packs of more teams, but fewer total game sales once you've sold to all the core customer base. 

I could be wrong on that. It's a big world and maybe there's 100x of your current sales base out there that would buy your game if they knew it existed and you had the production capacity to meet it. I don't really know. 

So the question is, if you could you make the knowledge of the existence of your game more widespread (i.e. advertising), do you think it would cause demand to explode or do you think that the core market is so niche that it wouldn't really increase sales by enough to "bet on yourself"?

--------------------

The other question is how much you value that vs what you have... I.e. I get asked often about homebrewing, "so when do you think you're going to open a brewery?" Uhh... Never. It's backbreaking labor, will require me to find investors or go into a ton of debt, and the return is minimal unless you are able to grow and scale--which is hard in a crowded market. And I compare that to a nice white-collar desk job which pays me a ton of money...

And most importantly, it keeps my hobby my hobby. I'll bet I'd enjoy brewing a LOT less if it were my job. You might enjoy Whoa Nellie a lot less if it were your job. 

So while you sound a little down of late about your job, there's a certain value in having a school district job with a pension plan, a 10-month work year, and probably stellar medical benefits (speaking based on my wife's best friend who works for the Long Beach school district--she's got better benefits than my giant multinational corporation plan which is REALLY good)... Maybe these things aren't true in Arizona... Again, I don't know. But sometimes when you get into those situations, it makes sense to stick things out until you hit the benefit windows that open up, and then something like Whoa Nellie becomes a job you can do while you've got pension dollars rolling in...
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: OrangeAfroMan on November 09, 2023, 09:17:54 PM
Good question - the existing market is how you describe it.  It's older guys who grew up in the 60s playing Bowl Bound or the pro equivalent and have the time and money to explore newer card/dice games.  But it's not a huge market.  I simply found a hole between 100% realistic possibilities and a low% generic game.  It's the game I was looking for.

BUT, there's unexplored market(s) of younger customers, which would have been easier to acquire when the whole board game interest jumped 6-8-10 years ago.  But every era has its sports fans and there are young ones out there that grew up on devices and may find a novel interest in physical cards/dice.  But that would require a tik tok account and wacky thumbnails and faux crazy-energy vids that last 12 seconds, etc.

Pass.

I do have a lot of repeat customers and a ton of other ideas.  All-Decade teams for individual schools and conferences, some kind of express version (esp for the low-focused youngins), etc.

If I had worker bees, I'd be freed up to explore ideas and tweak existing things.  Hell, I haven't played my own game in like 6+ months. 

Ideally, an existing company sees it, likes it, and buys it.  I'd have some money and free time on my hands, lol.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Gigem on November 21, 2023, 11:16:02 AM
OK I wanted to update this thread.  I met with a financial advisor last week who specializes with the retirement nuances of my company.  Here is what I will lose if I leave before age 50:  My pension will grow at 6% if I leave early, 8%  if I make 50.  It also depends on how long I defer it, obviously if I take it immediately it won't make any difference ( I doubt I will).  My pension will pretty much suck no matter how you slice it, I'm leaning towards it not making much of a difference either way unless I defer it until I'm in my 60's.  

I lose the option of having a level income on my pension.  This means that I could make more until I hit the age for SS, then my pension will go down but my total income will stay the same.  It's a neutral for me, he said he almost never recommends it unless there are extenuating circumstances (not projected to live long).  

I lose the ability to have retiree insurance, but basically I can buy the same insurance for about $300 more on the open market. I'm leaning towards it not making much difference.  It's expensive ($1200+) with a high deductible. I think I can get similar coverage on the open market for about the same cost.  

Right now I'm leaning towards retiring next year and doing my business full time.  Unless the economy really slows or something else happens to throw everything out of whack I'm probably going to let my boss know after January 1 that I intend to retire in 2024.  Probably about March-May time frame, it kinda depends.  I'm hoping they will offer a few people buyouts (as they are known to do) and I can take about a year's worth of severance with me when I leave.   
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on November 21, 2023, 11:18:59 AM
It's nice to have options, and you have some good ones. Kudos to you for making it happen.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on November 21, 2023, 11:52:09 AM
Best wishes from all of us, it's a kind of gutsy move of course, but I'm betting on you.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Gigem on March 25, 2024, 01:37:11 PM
OK I thought it would be a good time to update this thread.  

We did just about $600,000 in business last year.  We really didn't start doing high cost jobs until July, so basically we made 90% of our revenue in half the year.  

I didn't make a dime, in fact I had to put money back into it to keep afloat.  All the money either went back into the business for capital expenses (equipment), or payroll, taxes, insurance, etc.  Plus, as a newer company, we had more than our fair share of f' ups.  The things I learned in 6 months astound me.  Not saying we're perfect, because we're still fucking up, but I'd say I'm 50% better right now than I was in July of 2023.  

2024 started very, very slowly.  I overbid a few jobs and didn't win, and that cost me 3-4 jobs that would have paid the bills.  I had to put several $10,000 into the business just to stay afloat and pay vendors.  I won't make the same mistake next year, we will work for break-even in January/February if necessary.  I really need to work on raising prices, but right now as a new company I'm stuck competing on price and not quality.  I hope that changes this year.  

March is a lot better, we've been getting a steady flow of work and made several big projects happen over the last few weeks.  Our skillset and competence is much better, although we did have one f'up last week that put us behind after some very good weeks.  My oldest son has been a real driver, he has put his all into this and has really grown.  We've had our share of hiccups, but starting to see some real successes.  My youngest son has been working too, but I haven't been pushing him too hard yet.  

I lost one employee last year that I wasn't sad to see go.  He was good on some days, and so-so on others.  I miss his work output, and I have not been able to find a full replacement.  

One of my guys just turned 19.  He's a slow learner, but he shows up everyday, works hard, is honest, and getting more and more capable by the day.  I'm really glad to have him, and I've been raising his pay up slowly as I can afford to.  The guy that left, I had him raised up pretty good and the first time I had to cut hours in the fall he left the following week (cut hours down to 40).  He was making about $1,000 a week FWIW.  I was paying him $16/hr plus overtime.  

I'm still working my regular job, it gets harder by the week to juggle.  I really don't want to leave this job yet, it's the best job I've ever had and it's not hard.  I suspect that as soon as we have our first "profitable" month I'll start very seriously considering leaving.  What I mean by that is when we pay all our bills and have a very good surplus.  We had to buy so much equipment to get started that it sucked a lot of resources away last year, but our capital expenditures should be far less this year.  I say that, but I'm already eyeing other equipment to supplement what we've got.  There's always something you "need" to make things easier/faster/better.  It's definitely a balancing act.  

Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on March 25, 2024, 02:07:27 PM
Typical first year, I'd say.

Remind me. How young are you?
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: FearlessF on March 25, 2024, 02:11:03 PM
keep up the good work
the first year is obviously the toughest
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Gigem on March 25, 2024, 03:21:45 PM
48
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on March 25, 2024, 07:33:08 PM
It's a gutsy move, I think, I wouldn't do it, but I'm not gutsy at all.  No risk ...

It's also interesting, to me.

Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on March 25, 2024, 08:22:54 PM
I'm obviously retired, and doing pretty well overall.  My wife tells me all those years of "slaving away" paid off now, and it's true.  I didn't always hate my job, but I'd say half my career was pointless, a quarter was rewarding technically, and a quarter of it was near Hell for me.  I was paid well, and they put a lot of coin into my profit sharing account.

I'm disappointed in myself for not making more of my career, not so much in terms of promotions, but in doing some actual real work.  I did some, I am listed in over 40 US patents, but that largely is a game, maybe 2 of them meant something real.  If that.

I had one totally bogus idea I was forced into that was actually granted as a US Patent after I retired and I refused to sign the assignment, it was completely and totally a bogus idea.  They filed under "recalcitrant inventor" status.  I was sorry for the poor admin I made extra work for.

They had this consulting thing retirees could sign up for, and I did, with scant idea anyone would ever call me, and they didn't.  It all still irks me some, but I look at my numbers and figure it turned out OK, the point of a career really is to retire comfortably.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Gigem on March 25, 2024, 11:33:52 PM
Cincy, 

I take it you’re in your 60’s. The world was probably much different for you and your retirement. Did you have retiree medical insurance?  What about pension?  You mentioned stock options. 

These things are in the past for most companies. I’m right on the edge of what was, and what will be. They cut most of my benefits. I can still get retiree insurance if I make 50, but it’s expensive and marginally better than what I can buy on my own. They stopped our pensions right when I’m on the cusp of making the best returns ( my pension would have grown the most in my 50’s). 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: OrangeAfroMan on March 26, 2024, 12:58:43 AM
Arizona changed their cutoff for retirement benefits/timing some years back.  It happened 2-3 years after I moved here, so I'm under the old format, fortunately.  
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on March 26, 2024, 04:57:11 AM
Cincy,

I take it you’re in your 60’s. The world was probably much different for you and your retirement. Did you have retiree medical insurance?  What about pension?  You mentioned stock options.
I have retiree medical insurance.  I had no "pension" as such, but we had stock put into a retirement account each year.  It got to be a chunk, but it initially was entirely in the company's stock.  That changed a bit down the road and I could invest some of it in some mutual funds run by JP Morgan (who are not in my view very good at this for the customer).  When I retired, we devised a plan to dump all the company stock over time and diversify.  That worked out well for me.  The stock options were a relative pittance in comparison, but a nice little bump each year for ten years.  I don't have any now.

I started drawing SS when I hit 66, which also is a nice bump each month, and I'm on Medicare with the retiree health insurance added, it doesn't cost me much for both of us.  I pay $134 a month for two.

The stock plan still exists for new employees thought now it isn't as generous.  They called if a "profit sharing plan".
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on March 26, 2024, 09:08:24 AM
Cincy,

I take it you’re in your 60’s. The world was probably much different for you and your retirement. Did you have retiree medical insurance?  What about pension?  You mentioned stock options.

These things are in the past for most companies. I’m right on the edge of what was, and what will be. They cut most of my benefits. I can still get retiree insurance if I make 50, but it’s expensive and marginally better than what I can buy on my own. They stopped our pensions right when I’m on the cusp of making the best returns ( my pension would have grown the most in my 50’s).
He's 104 years young.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on March 26, 2024, 09:11:03 AM
I'm close to not being in my 60s.  And given our travels seem to take us to or near war zones, I may not make it.

Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Riffraft on March 26, 2024, 10:52:42 AM
I have 24 days until I officially retire. No old enough for Medicare and I don't have any retirement insurance, so I will be paying independently for a few years.  This was one of the reason my wife was initially hesitant to retire because of the cost of medical insurance, but an analysis showed we could retire, pay for insurance until medicare kicked it, fund the things we want to do and still shouldn't deplete our assets. So she was all gung-ho. 

I understand about war zones, we had a retirement cruise scheduled to go to Greece, Turkey, Egypt and Israel but it was cancelled. 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: iahawk15 on March 26, 2024, 10:56:51 AM

I'm still working my regular job, it gets harder by the week to juggle.  I really don't want to leave this job yet, it's the best job I've ever had and it's not hard.  I suspect that as soon as we have our first "profitable" month I'll start very seriously considering leaving.  What I mean by that is when we pay all our bills and have a very good surplus.  We had to buy so much equipment to get started that it sucked a lot of resources away last year, but our capital expenditures should be far less this year.  I say that, but I'm already eyeing other equipment to supplement what we've got.  There's always something you "need" to make things easier/faster/better.  It's definitely a balancing act. 


I didn't catch this thread the first time around and just read through the whole thing.

I left my job at the end of 2011 (age 32) due to massive corporate BS and our (wife and I) company had just broken into profitability (not ramen profitable, like barely above breakeven profitable). I cashed in my 401K (less than $100K) and "bet on myself" with the belief I could replace my salary within a year (about $45K at that time). We, in fact, did not replace my salary within the first year. Or the second year. I had two daughters under 5 years old. In retrospect, it was an insanely reckless decision.

As a result, we have run the gamut, financially. The girls were on Medicaid the first year, a humbling feeling. Then graduated to State assisted health care. Spent years cycling through 2-5% credit card loans to keep afloat. And then eventually crossed the threshold of not being able to directly contribute to our Roth IRA's.

The gist of the story is, if you're going to go all in, I suggest having a solid plan to compensate yourself. A good book on the subject is Profit First, by Mike Michalowicz. It is over simplistic at times, so consider it more a loose guide than turnkey game plan.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on March 26, 2024, 11:12:15 AM
Thanks for your perspective, it's useful.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on March 26, 2024, 11:19:55 AM
The gist of the story is, if you're going to go all in, I suggest having a solid plan to compensate yourself. A good book on the subject is Profit First, by Mike Michalowicz. It is over simplistic at times, so consider it more a loose guide than turnkey game plan.
I didn't read that book (or any other books other than cookbooks) but what I always said was:

"If you aren't making a profit, your work is a hobby".

Does anyone really want work to be a hobby? Maybe artists or musicians, I guess?

Thankfully my wife was making big bank when I started out.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on March 26, 2024, 11:20:56 AM
I'm making a profit as an author.  I reported $16 in income on my taxes last year.  Sales are up so far this year.

Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: iahawk15 on March 26, 2024, 11:28:17 AM
I didn't read that book (or any other books other than cookbooks) but what I always said was:

"If you aren't making a profit, your work is a hobby".

Does anyone really want work to be a hobby? Maybe artists or musicians, I guess?

Thankfully my wife was making big bank when I started out.
The book is targeted toward Gigem's situation; business owners with good revenue but can't find a way to actually pay themselves. It addresses the mentality that you must throw all profit back into the company for the sake of growth while you're personally trying to keep your head above water.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: betarhoalphadelta on March 26, 2024, 11:57:16 AM
I'm making a profit as an author.  I reported $16 in income on my taxes last year.  Sales are up so far this year.


What does that work out to as an hourly wage? :57:
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on March 26, 2024, 12:10:04 PM
The book is targeted toward Gigem's situation; business owners with good revenue but can't find a way to actually pay themselves. It addresses the mentality that you must throw all profit back into the company for the sake of growth while you're personally trying to keep your head above water.
Yep. My company started making a profit at about 6 months. I had 4 people at the time. Never missed a payroll.

I didn't start taking a check until about 7 months, and at year end I took a distribution based on my stock basis. You pay FAR less taxes on distributions than you do on payroll. But you cannot do all distributions and no payroll. SSA and Medicare don't like it and it's actually not legal.

So, at year end, I'd take what I could and then loan the company money at prime +2% interest. Collections are always slow in January and February so there was no choice in the matter.

You need to have zero in the checkbook at year end, otherwise the owners have to claim the pass-through income on the K-1.

It's not easy and it's not for everyone. 23-24 years of personal experience tells me that.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: FearlessF on March 26, 2024, 12:32:51 PM
I left my job at the end of 2011 (age 32) due to massive corporate BS and our (wife and I) company had just broken into profitability (not ramen profitable, like barely above breakeven profitable). I cashed in my 401K (less than $100K) and "bet on myself" with the belief I could replace my salary within a year (about $45K at that time). We, in fact, did not replace my salary within the first year. Or the second year. I had two daughters under 5 years old. In retrospect, it was an insanely reckless decision.

I had a very good opportunity to buy a business when my daughters were the same age.
My wife was a dental hygienist and had no benefits.
That was too much risk for me.
I passed on the opportunity.
I don't regret the decision. 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: iahawk15 on March 26, 2024, 12:57:11 PM
I had a very good opportunity to buy a business when my daughters were the same age.
My wife was a dental hygienist and had no benefits.
That was too much risk for me.
I passed on the opportunity.
I don't regret the decision.
Everything worked out, so I don't regret it, but it was very risky. I had a college degree and a CDL so I knew I could always go get a job if it came to that. I have reflected on it often, I'm glad I committed to building something, but I would have approached my exit differently.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: iahawk15 on March 26, 2024, 01:09:47 PM
Yep. My company started making a profit at about 6 months. I had 4 people at the time. Never missed a payroll.

I didn't start taking a check until about 7 months, and at year end I took a distribution based on my stock basis. You pay FAR less taxes on distributions than you do on payroll. But you cannot do all distributions and no payroll. SSA and Medicare don't like it and it's actually not legal.

So, at year end, I'd take what I could and then loan the company money at prime +2% interest. Collections are always slow in January and February so there was no choice in the matter.

You need to have zero in the checkbook at year end, otherwise the owners have to claim the pass-through income on the K-1.

It's not easy and it's not for everyone. 23-24 years of personal experience tells me that.
Yeah, "our" company is technically set up as an S-Corp with my wife holding 100% ownership. I was a stay-at-home dad on paper for a couple years until our accountant convinced me that not taking a salary was going to become a problem sooner or later. I've taken a "reasonable" salary since and my wife takes a very minimal salary with a year-end max employee deferral W2 that gets her up into the "reasonable" range. Everything else comes through monthly / quarterly distributions.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on March 26, 2024, 01:41:07 PM
Everything worked out, so I don't regret it, but it was very risky. I had a college degree and a CDL so I knew I could always go get a job if it came to that. I have reflected on it often, I'm glad I committed to building something, but I would have approached my exit differently.
What have you done about it?
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: iahawk15 on March 26, 2024, 02:38:21 PM
What have you done about it?
I don't think I understand the question. I was speaking about how I left my job for self-employment. Are you wanting to know what would I have done differently? Or are you asking how I plan to exit our current business?
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on March 26, 2024, 02:55:20 PM
Current, really.

Did you have a rough exit from your old employer? I've had one and it was not fun.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: iahawk15 on March 26, 2024, 03:21:36 PM
Current, really.

Did you have a rough exit from your old employer? I've had one and it was not fun.
Our current exit plan is non-existent. Two person company, no SOP's or process documentation. I can't hold our licenses without her qualifications, she can't run the company without my technical knowledge.

I lost a good friend to a work accident last month and it set off some alarm bells for getting our shit together.

We have a portfolio of five websites that could be sold off for roughly 1.5 million, but the company as a whole would not currently be an attractive acquisition target.

Work exit was rough, but not personal. PepsiCo bought our corporate distributorship then gutted pay and benefits over a period of 18 months. I made it less than a year after that.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Gigem on March 26, 2024, 09:46:43 PM
Really great contribution to the thread iahawk.  

The hard part for me is I’m ok with my job. And I’m in the home stretch with regards to whatever benefits there are available to me, plus a great 401k match, and decent cheap medical insurance. I think the whole family is covered for about $500-600 per month. Low deductible. Of course I’ve hardly ever needed much insurance, but the possibility is always there. 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on March 27, 2024, 07:24:38 AM
Our current exit plan is non-existent. Two person company, no SOP's or process documentation. I can't hold our licenses without her qualifications, she can't run the company without my technical knowledge.

I lost a good friend to a work accident last month and it set off some alarm bells for getting our shit together.

We have a portfolio of five websites that could be sold off for roughly 1.5 million, but the company as a whole would not currently be an attractive acquisition target.

Work exit was rough, but not personal. PepsiCo bought our corporate distributorship then gutted pay and benefits over a period of 18 months. I made it less than a year after that.
Do you have an operating agreement and shareholder agreement?
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on March 27, 2024, 07:33:49 AM
I started work with noble intentions, I suppose, and enthusiasm and drive and whatever else, and ended the last decade or so "Get me through this so I can retire."  I viewed work solely as a means to an end, comfortable retirement.

I admire you folks who can go out on your own taking risks and hopefully doing well with what you want to do.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Riffraft on March 27, 2024, 05:53:09 PM
I started work with noble intentions, I suppose, and enthusiasm and drive and whatever else, and ended the last decade or so "Get me through this so I can retire."  I viewed work solely as a means to an end, comfortable retirement.

I admire you folks who can go out on your own taking risks and hopefully doing well with what you want to do.
I agree with both of your sentiments 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Gigem on May 07, 2024, 09:20:28 AM
So a funny thing happened from the time I started this thread and now.  When I started this thread, I was 47 and at least 2-3 calendar years away from retirement.  Nothing has changed for me, except now I'm 48 and basically 1.5 years away from being able to say I'm retired.  I'll leave stuff on the table, but 2025 is not that far away.  I'll have to wait until the end of the year (2025) to make the finish line, but it seems really close.  I made a remark to a co-worker in the know that I don't know how much longer I can keep this up, and he said sure you can.  So I guess unless something unexpected happens between now and Dec 2025 I'm going to finish out my term.  

So in about 576 days I will turn 50 and have 22 years of service and officially eligible to retire with "full" benefits.  Full is in quotes because I won't get as much as I could if I stayed another 10 years.  I'll probably not actually pull the trigger until 2026, as my vacation and stuff will re-set so I'll probably wait until the first quarter to put in my paperwork.  
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on May 07, 2024, 09:27:27 AM
A good friend of mine in Cincy just announced his retirement after 37 years working in the power industry.  Another couple was just visiting and the husband is looking at it next year.  They both had "discussions" with me, I can't of course provide any hard advice, just some thoughts.  It's often a complex transition in many ways.  I suggest getting real tax advice in most cases.  And sign up for Medicare when you hit 65, don't miss that window.  When to take SS depends on other stuff.

I'm delighted to be retired, I mostly do what I want every day.  
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on May 07, 2024, 09:27:39 AM
How is the new endeavor coming along?
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on May 07, 2024, 09:31:36 AM
My last day of work will be January 2, 2029. I'll be 62 on January 3.

I will take SS immediately, as I don't trust how long the program will continue. Plus, I'd have to hit about 80 to realize the difference if I were to wait until 67. Not happening.

My wife is taking it already. She's 62. We pretend it doesn't exist and just put it away, maxing out our Roth contributions first, and then just savings.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Gigem on May 07, 2024, 09:33:24 AM
How is the new endeavor coming along?
Early part of this year almost killed us, I had to put several tens of thousands into the business just to pay bills.  March was good, April was OK, and we're getting better all the time.  My son will be home from college this week and will take a good amount of the load off me, and my other son will be out for the summer to help as well.  We need to get more efficient at what we do, and we need to get prices up ASAP.  I have some employees that are getting more experience all the time and getting more efficient.  So it's up and down overall, but trending up.  
Building seems to be strong here, we've put in at least 3-4 systems for new homes this year with several on the books.  
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on May 07, 2024, 09:33:53 AM
The SSTF now is projected to run dry in 2035.   IF nothing is done, it would cut payments by about 25%, folks would still get a check.

I EXPECT a series of bandaids from Congress.  They show no inclination NOW to do anything in any bipartisan manner.  Any suggestion of any charge is the third rail thing.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Gigem on May 07, 2024, 09:44:24 AM
As I've often stated, I just wish the politicians would do something, instead of kicking the can down the road.  Cut spending, raise taxes, shrink the gov't, whatever it takes.  I personally think some measure of all three could be combined, especially shrinking the gov't and cutting spending.  I think we could cut so much wasteful spending (Ukraine $$$ and other bullshit) it would go a long way, and be smart about what taxes to raise and when.  
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on May 07, 2024, 09:47:16 AM
I wish a lot of things, but they tend not to happen for various reasons.  So, I no longer expect much of anything good coming from Congress.

Fixing SS should be fairly easy, but isn't.  It would require serious compromise that would "PO both sides".  Politicians don't want it, so it doesn't happen.

As for spending and the deficit, it's not going to get fixed, ever.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on May 07, 2024, 09:59:36 AM
As I've often stated, I just wish the politicians would do something, instead of kicking the can down the road.  Cut spending, raise taxes, shrink the gov't, whatever it takes.  I personally think some measure of all three could be combined, especially shrinking the gov't and cutting spending.  I think we could cut so much wasteful spending (Ukraine $$$ and other bullshit) it would go a long way, and be smart about what taxes to raise and when. 
No need to raise taxes, but everything else, yeah. The Government is FAR too big, and it's at most all levels in most all places. Municipal. County. State. Federal.

The town I moved from in Illinois has a Village Manager making $300K+/-, with a retirement income that will be the same (base pay) as his last day of employment - for life. He is now 57 and is one year away from full retirement. This is not sustainable.

(https://i.imgur.com/AZNKSui.png)
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on May 07, 2024, 10:02:23 AM
There is literally no way Congress is going to meaningfully cut spending, zero.  If magically they did, they'd be out of office next election.

It's not a viable System.  They get elected promising to spend our (and borrowed money) on things voters seem to want, and lowering taxes often as not.

Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on May 07, 2024, 10:06:35 AM
No need to raise taxes, but everything else, yeah. The Government is FAR too big, and it's at most all levels in most all places. Municipal. County. State. Federal.

The town I moved from in Illinois has a Village Manager making $300K+/-, with a retirement income that will be the same (base pay) as his last day of employment - for life. He is now 57 and is one year away from full retirement. This is not sustainable.

(https://i.imgur.com/AZNKSui.png)
(https://i.imgur.com/niVglHf.png)
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: FearlessF on May 07, 2024, 10:10:56 AM
The SSTF now is projected to run dry in 2035.  IF nothing is done, it would cut payments by about 25%, folks would still get a check.

I EXPECT a series of bandaids from Congress.  They show no inclination NOW to do anything in any bipartisan manner.  Any suggestion of any charge is the third rail thing.
and there's literally no way congress will let SSTF run dry or cut payments by 25%

the age group that cares about SS is the largest voting block
regardless of which side of the aisle or any other political leanings, they all want their SS check

similar to the idea that we will ALL be driving electric vehicles powered by windmills in 2035 - kick the can down the road another decade
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on May 07, 2024, 10:16:04 AM
similar to the idea that we will ALL be driving electric vehicles powered by windmills in 2035 - kick the can down the road another decade
This of course isn't the "plan", such as there is a plan.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: betarhoalphadelta on May 07, 2024, 10:21:27 AM
This of course isn't the "plan", such as there is a plan.
It's the "plan" in California, set in place by a Governor who won't be Governor in 2035, so...

...it'll change sometime between now and 2035 when they realize the "plan" is unworkable. 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: FearlessF on May 07, 2024, 10:21:51 AM
there is no plan for anything

no plan for green energy
no plan for the future of SS
no plan for affordable housing or living wages

Hell, as far as I know, the SEC and the B1G don't have a plan for breaking away from the NCAA
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on May 07, 2024, 10:24:31 AM
It's the "plan" in California, set in place by a Governor who won't be Governor in 2035, so...

...it'll change sometime between now and 2035 when they realize the "plan" is unworkable.
No, it isn't, even there.  They won't all be driving EVs in California in 2035 at all, even if the rule stands.  They won't even be at 50%.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: betarhoalphadelta on May 07, 2024, 10:28:06 AM
No, it isn't, even there.  They won't all be driving EVs in California in 2035 at all, even if the rule stands.  They won't even be at 50%.
Ahh, sorry. I sorta misread it. That "plan" or "rule" says that only EVs will be sold in CA starting 2035.

I'm saying that rule is NOT going to stand. 

You're correct that it won't take existing ICEVs off the road by 2035. 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: FearlessF on May 07, 2024, 10:47:08 AM
a rule is not a plan

the governor has no plan
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on May 07, 2024, 11:15:23 AM
Clowns don't make plans.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: FearlessF on May 07, 2024, 11:50:40 AM
how do they all manage to get into that little car w/o a plan?
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on May 07, 2024, 12:10:17 PM
Politicians often set some kind of plan or goal or something that takes effect long after they leave office.

I suspect many Californians think they will have no choice in 2035 but to drive an EV.  
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: betarhoalphadelta on May 07, 2024, 12:15:06 PM
Politicians often set some kind of plan or goal or something that takes effect long after they leave office.

I suspect many Californians think they will have no choice in 2035 but to drive an EV. 
Well it comes down to different things. This isn't a plan or a goal; it's a rule. Assuming the rule is legal (i.e. it'll withstand a lawsuit), it is now in place that only zero emission vehicles are legal to sell starting in 2035. 

This isn't like the Paris accords, where you "commit" to an emissions target but don't have plans/rules that force that commitment. In that case it's basically a goal with no plan. 

This is a rule with no plan, but the plan doesn't matter to those making the rule. The plan is for someone else to figure out. 

That, of course, is if the rule isn't overturned (or more likely the implementation date will be pushed out) because it's economically infeasible. We often think of law or rule as a top-down system, but lawmakers know that if their rules piss off too many people, they get voted out of office, so they will often modify a law/rule before it is implemented if it won't actually work. 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on May 07, 2024, 12:22:19 PM
Yup, some "rule", which is akin to a notional aspirational attempt to sounds fancy.

It's 11 years out.  Can the infrastructure change that rapidly by then?  I think we all think not, but it's possible.  And maybe "they" ram it through but I suspect, as you note, it will be very unpopular when it hits the fan.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on May 07, 2024, 12:42:27 PM
What are your plans for retirement, if you're not already?

If you are, what do you do to fill your time?

Obviously, I know a lot of retired people here and they mostly keep very busy.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: betarhoalphadelta on May 07, 2024, 12:43:10 PM
Yup, some "rule", which is akin to a notional aspirational attempt to sounds fancy.

It's 11 years out.  Can the infrastructure change that rapidly by then?  I think we all think not, but it's possible.  And maybe "they" ram it through but I suspect, as you note, it will be very unpopular when it hits the fan.
Right, but there's still a big difference between a goal and a rule. 

A company may have a goal to get to net zero by 2040, for example. They may have plans already in place to get there, whether complete or acknowledging a "gap" between plan and goal that still needs to be closed. But even with a goal and a plan, that's not a rule. If the company isn't net zero  by 2040, that doesn't mean that the government or Wall St will intervene and give them penalties. 

A rule is something that is currently GOING to happen enshrined in law. If as you point out by 2035 the SSTF is exhausted, there is a rule in place for what will happen. It would trigger an immediate and significant cut in benefits. That's nobody's "goal" IMHO, but that will happen if nobody changes the rule. 

Do we all think that will actually happen? No. We think the rule will be changed before then. But if they don't, the rule is already in effect and will happen as prescribed. It's not just some "goal". 

The same is true with ICEVs in CA. Newsom didn't set a "goal." He had (as I understand it) an executive order stating this rule, and the California Air Resources Board (CARB) has enacted said rule so it is now enshrined in law. Can it be changed/modified? Yes. Will it? Probably. But it's more than a "goal". 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on May 07, 2024, 12:55:56 PM
We're in agreement, it's a "rule" which likely will get changed.

It might as well be a goal or plan or notional aspiration.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: betarhoalphadelta on May 07, 2024, 12:56:52 PM
We're in agreement, it's a "rule" which likely will get changed.

It might as well be a goal or plan or notional aspiration.
Fair, we're in agreement. 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on May 07, 2024, 01:29:54 PM
I gather they call it a "mandate", technically.

Californians bought record numbers of electric cars CalMatters (https://calmatters.org/environment/2024/02/california-electric-cars-industry-slowdown/)

Some intimidating figures in that.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on May 07, 2024, 01:44:31 PM
What are your plans for retirement, if you're not already?

If you are, what do you do to fill your time?

Obviously, I know a lot of retired people here and they mostly keep very busy.
We will probably use our boat a lot more than we do, and I'll be golfing (!). Probably more travel than now.

Not sure if I will fully retire. Maybe work part time, as needed. Maybe teach. It's up in the air.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on May 07, 2024, 01:46:28 PM
I thought about what I'd do, and my primary central answer is "Whatever I want."  I don't feel guilty if I spend all day inside on a nice day if I want.

I read a good bit, if I feel like it.  We walk a lot of course, and fairly often have lunch somewhere out.  Travel is of course way up.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: FearlessF on May 07, 2024, 01:58:14 PM
What are your plans for retirement, if you're not already?
a round of golf a day, weather permitting
message board pot stirring
traveling around the united states visiting with friends and relatives - mostly driving
Possibly moving to a warmer location to be able to play more golf or be closer to my daughters or brother (just possible at this point)
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Riffraft on May 07, 2024, 01:58:42 PM
What are your plans for retirement, if you're not already?

If you are, what do you do to fill your time?

Obviously, I know a lot of retired people here and they mostly keep very busy.
What are your plans for retirement, if you're not already?

If you are, what do you do to fill your time?

Obviously, I know a lot of retired people here and they mostly keep very busy.
Right now on a 30 day combo cruise and touring Europe. After that a few weeks home then mexican riveria.  Then 3 weeks home and on to Alaska.  And then a similar vein for the next year and a half to 2 years.  Getting the travel in while I am healthy and mobile.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on May 07, 2024, 02:01:58 PM
Right now on a 30 day combo cruise and touring Europe. After that a few weeks home then mexican riveria.  Then 3 weeks home and on to Alaska.  And then a similar vein for the next year and a half to 2 years.  Getting the travel in while I am healthy and mobile.
Huge key there.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: FearlessF on May 07, 2024, 02:22:23 PM
yup, my plan to play a round of golf per day weather permitting, might be more often limited by my health than weather
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: betarhoalphadelta on May 07, 2024, 02:42:33 PM
Getting the travel in while I am healthy and mobile.
I got a long time to be retired, but I guess I'm putting in the work now to make sure that I'm still going to be healthy and mobile when I retire, unlike my parents. 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on May 07, 2024, 02:58:04 PM
I got a long time to be retired, but I guess I'm putting in the work now to make sure that I'm still going to be healthy and mobile when I retire, unlike my parents.
That's what I'm working on as well, although I'm not as far along as you are.

The broken leg set me back in January 2022. Then sciatica in 2023. Had another back surgery (minor) in February to fix that.

Lots of strength training now, and balance work.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: utee94 on May 07, 2024, 04:38:31 PM
yup, my plan to play a round of golf per day weather permitting, might be more often limited by my health than weather
You should move to Florida, "weather-permitting" means you can play every day over there.  It's paradise!
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on May 07, 2024, 04:40:16 PM
Sometimes it's too windy to play. But you can tee off from here to some course in Miami, if driving distance is your goal.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: FearlessF on May 07, 2024, 04:41:39 PM
after watching a Tiktok from Dani, who goes by @gasstationnachos in Austin, I'm sure as hell not moving there
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: betarhoalphadelta on May 07, 2024, 05:09:22 PM
Sometimes it's too windy to play. But you can tee off from here to some course in Miami, if driving distance is your goal.
Too windy?

Ask a Scot.

Nae wind, nae rain, it's nae golf!
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on May 07, 2024, 05:18:10 PM
Meh. Sustained 155 MPH with 225+ gusts for 8 hours. The Scots got nothing on that.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: betarhoalphadelta on May 07, 2024, 05:28:45 PM
Meh. Sustained 155 MPH with 225+ gusts for 8 hours. The Scots got nothing on that.
That, and you have literal dinosaurs waddling around? 

Screw it. I prefer Austin.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on May 07, 2024, 05:31:53 PM
"If it stings, crawls, flies and bites, it lives here, 365/24/7."

- Florida Man
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: betarhoalphadelta on May 07, 2024, 05:33:42 PM
"If it stings, crawls, flies and bites, it lives here, 365/24/7."

- Florida Man
At least in Australia, where everything in the entire continent is literally trying to kill you, you get to hear a cool accent. 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: FearlessF on May 07, 2024, 06:06:12 PM
and good beer

unlike Austin
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: MrNubbz on May 07, 2024, 07:01:58 PM
At least in Australia, where everything in the entire continent is literally trying to kill you, you get to hear a cool accent.
Ha! No Shyt 5 of the deadliest creatures(sans man) living there.Salt water crocs,bullsharks,box jellyfish,some deadly spider,some deadly snake. Plus it's at least as hot as Austin - they're prolly sister cities.Oh and if you do go don't drink the Foster's

And the 'roos can kick the snot out of you two
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: FearlessF on May 07, 2024, 07:24:52 PM
(https://i.imgur.com/VuGhakh.png)
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: OrangeAfroMan on May 07, 2024, 11:01:50 PM
"If it stings, crawls, flies and bites, it lives here, 365/24/7."

- Florida Man
And he's just talking about relatives...
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Riffraft on May 08, 2024, 06:51:56 AM
You should move to Florida, "weather-permitting" means you can play every day over there.  It's paradise!
Phoenix much better no humidity  and year around holf
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on May 08, 2024, 07:29:25 AM
If you can derive some sense of accomplishment in your work, that is fantastic.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on May 08, 2024, 08:13:30 AM
If you can derive some sense of accomplishment in your work, that is fantastic.
The thing I feel best about as I get into my waning years is that I've provided a good job and good living for a lot of people, for a long time.

The next best thing is that my company is actually worth something and it is paying me to go away.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on May 08, 2024, 08:16:40 AM
I have some fleeting notions of having done something useful in my time, but oddly enough, much of my best work, IMHO, was either unrecognized or dismissed by the higher ups, while I got credit for some things I viewed as trivial and trite and not very original.

Life often was upside down.  

Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: FearlessF on May 08, 2024, 08:43:04 AM
some accomplishments over 25 years ago killing hogs and other meat packing projects

Some accomplishments building networks to serve cooperative small town customers with internet service

and the past 2 1/2 years accomplished building a solid client base in Iowa and Nebraska from scratch

nothing earth shattering, but a good sense about being productive

my only failure was my college career (dropped out)
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on May 08, 2024, 08:45:53 AM
The good news is "we" get to decide what was useful and rewarding, not someone else.

We largely don't get to decide which gets rewarded by the bosses.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: FearlessF on May 08, 2024, 08:47:54 AM
a good boss makes all the difference

regardless of the rewards
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on May 08, 2024, 08:50:54 AM
I had two bosses I'd consider good out of about 30.  Another 15 or so were neutral, useless, pointless, lazy, but not negative, and the rest were frankly damaging to any prospects.

I had one bosses boss who liked me and was good, another one liked me but was horrible otherwise.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: MrNubbz on May 08, 2024, 08:53:55 AM
Phoenix much better no humidity  and year around holf
Wha!!!Friends moved there 2 yrs ago to be closer to family.But he comes back and stays in N.Ohio for much of the summer/fall.His adult daughters stay with mom one is finishing her 2nd yr at ASU. He hates the heat he'd email us how many days in a row were over 110°. He's a holf whore to and likes the greens and greenery up here
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: FearlessF on May 08, 2024, 08:54:39 AM
yup, my boss before the current one caused me to plan to retire early at 59 1/2
miserable
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on May 08, 2024, 09:00:04 AM
Wha!!!Friends moved there 2 yrs ago to be closer to family.But he comes back and stays in N.Ohio for much of the summer/fall.His adult daughters stay with mom one is finishing her 2nd yr at ASU. He hates the heat he'd email us how many days in a row were over 110°. He's a holf whore to and likes the greens and greenery up here
They will run out of water eventually.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: MrNubbz on May 08, 2024, 09:39:06 AM
yup, my boss before the current one caused me to plan to retire early at 59 1/2
miserable
HA! not all violence amongst employees is the work of a mad man.Some problematic piss ants with position kept pushing the wrong buttons
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: MrNubbz on May 08, 2024, 09:39:59 AM
They will run out of water eventually.
Not if - when
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on May 08, 2024, 09:41:28 AM
I would just reprocess waste water, maybe they do it.  A waste treatment plant can produce potable water at some additional expense (tertiary).

I know they lose a lot to evaporation and leakage.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: FearlessF on May 08, 2024, 09:41:54 AM
yup, I'm happy to have left before I acted in a way towards him that I'd regret

no sense tainting a 23 1/2 year career at a place in my home town
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: MrNubbz on May 08, 2024, 09:50:18 AM
It was more than probable myself and others were going to whip a boss like a rented mule.I'm getting to old for that shit but the thought of busting a burning slug into his ass brought a smile to my face. But then he looks like a victim
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on May 08, 2024, 09:51:22 AM
I would just reprocess waste water, maybe they do it.  A waste treatment plant can produce potable water at some additional expense (tertiary).

I know they lose a lot to evaporation and leakage.
They do some, for irrigation, and more recently (10 years or so), they use reclaimed water for flushing toilets. Adds a lot to the construction costs (double the pipe/install), but there is not much of a choice to be made out there.

And yes, there are losses.

One of my friends lived in this development until he moved to Palm Beach Gardens. Lots and lots of loss potential in that pond. There are thousands more like it out there.


(https://i.imgur.com/VSDZN2u.jpeg)

My MIL lives here:


(https://i.imgur.com/ca2sfG5.jpeg)
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on May 08, 2024, 11:42:24 AM
As Social Security faces insolvency, these are key factors to watch (cnbc.com) (https://www.cnbc.com/2024/05/08/as-social-security-faces-insolvency-these-are-key-factors-to-watch.html)
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on May 08, 2024, 12:02:00 PM


It's obvious that spending needs to be cut. Where?

How about defense?

How about not forgiving massive debts?

Wasteful Government agencies. Pick from this list:

A-Z index of U.S. government departments and agencies | USAGov (https://www.usa.gov/agency-index)

**********************************

It's also obvious that revenues need to go up. I'd like to see a feasible plan to achieve this.

A larger contribution to Medicare and Social Security would help.

A 0.8 percent increase on SS, from 6.2 to 7 percent (14 percent total).

Take Medicare from 1.45 to 2 percent (4 percent total).

Then there is all this BS on taxing the wealthy more. Show me how and show me why.

Higher corporate taxes? If your goal is to cut jobs, have at it. I don't condone this at all.

We need more jobs, which leads to more people paying taxes. Duh.






Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: betarhoalphadelta on May 08, 2024, 12:54:42 PM
As Social Security faces insolvency, these are key factors to watch (cnbc.com) (https://www.cnbc.com/2024/05/08/as-social-security-faces-insolvency-these-are-key-factors-to-watch.html)
At which point I have to mention, yet again and as always, that Social Security is ALREADY insolvent. It now, and has for several years, been paying out more money than it takes in. 

The SSTF, is not an account full of "money" that the SSTF can draw from to pay their shortages. It's full of promises to print or tax money and give it to the Social Security program to meet its obligations. 

The Social Security Trust Fund is, and always has been, a bullshit setup that is used to fool Americans into thinking the system's structural problems are farther down the road than now. 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on May 08, 2024, 01:00:14 PM
I think the SSTF is a real thing, personally.  They invest in special T bills just like other people and corporations, and that "money" there has real value.

They have no authority to borrow.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: betarhoalphadelta on May 08, 2024, 02:16:36 PM
I think the SSTF is a real thing, personally.  They invest in special T bills just like other people and corporations, and that "money" there has real value.

They have no authority to borrow.
It's a "real thing", sure. It contains Treasury Bills. 

But again, that's just a promise that the Treasury will either print money (i.e. sell T Bills to other investors and use the funds to repay SS) or will tax Americans for the money to repay SS. 

It's a pretty damn good promise, of course. I believe the special T Bills that are issued to the SSTF are possibly the most senior debt that the entire government has? 

But it's still just a promise to raise money to pay it back, not an actual pile of money. 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on May 08, 2024, 02:20:35 PM
There aren't many actual piles of money anywhere, certainly not trillions.  It's all invested in something.  

And dollar bills are not more substantial than Treasury bills.

Insolvent, to me, means they can't pay current bills, and they can, and do.  But I suppose all this is just terminology.  The main thing is they can still pay about 75% of their obligations even if nothing is done, and nearly everyone expects Congress to "do something" somewhere along the line.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on May 08, 2024, 02:22:30 PM
I bought my first stock in 1978, 30 shares of Abbott Labs.  I got the actual script at the time, a fancy piece of paper saying I owned it.  Now of course is all somewhere in the interwebz.

Most of my bills comes as emails, and I schlepp "money" to pay them using the interwebz.  I never see a dime of it.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: betarhoalphadelta on May 08, 2024, 02:52:46 PM
There aren't many actual piles of money anywhere, certainly not trillions.  It's all invested in something. 

And dollar bills are not more substantial than Treasury bills.

Insolvent, to me, means they can't pay current bills, and they can, and do.  But I suppose all this is just terminology.  The main thing is they can still pay about 75% of their obligations even if nothing is done, and nearly everyone expects Congress to "do something" somewhere along the line.
Perhaps I shouldn't have said "insolvent". I retract that. 

Think of the government as a large conglomerate company like GE. It has revenues and costs. One division of the company (let's say GE Healthcare) is profitable while another division (let's say GE Aerospace) is not. 

What you're talking about here is GE Healthcare using its profits to buy bonds from the GE corporate entity, and then the GE corporate entity using that money to fund GE Aerospace's obligations. That money has been spent. 

As time passes, business conditions for GE Healthcare sour and now they want to cash in on those bonds. Where does GE corporate get the money? Either from raiding other profitable divisions or having to run hat in hand to the equity markets. But they're all under one stock ticker, so either option is a negative for the corporation as a whole. 

------------------

In the case of SS, all of those "excess" contributions that were turned into T Bills and put into the SSTF have been spent by the government. To repay those T Bills, they have to either borrow more money or raise taxes on Americans. Either they're going to continue ballooning the national debt, or it comes out of OUR pockets. 

I'm not saying it won't be paid back. I'm saying that paying it back is choosing between two bad options. 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on May 08, 2024, 02:57:05 PM
Again, we really agree aside from some terminology of no real import.

So long as the government can borrow as it does huge amounts with relatively little problem, it will.  And when it can no longer do so, well, it'll be largely over.

I don't see any viable solution or prospect of real change.  Elected officials who really started to do what is needed would  be quickly voted out of office.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: betarhoalphadelta on May 08, 2024, 03:21:01 PM
Again, we really agree aside from some terminology of no real import.

So long as the government can borrow as it does huge amounts with relatively little problem, it will.  And when it can no longer do so, well, it'll be largely over.

I don't see any viable solution or prospect of real change.  Elected officials who really started to do what is needed would  be quickly voted out of office.
Right. 

But do you understand what I'm saying not about how the system works, but how the system was designed to fool voters? Even naming it the "Social Security Trust Fund" gives off a certain idea, a "trust fund" being some large account that you've squared away to draw on. It's designed to make voters think that Social Security has actually been saving money for several decades, and now "someone" will pay it back to the program.

But who pays it back is us

That money was never saved. It was lent to the rest of the federal government and spent. Over decades. Essentially to make people think that income taxes didn't need to be as high as they actually needed to be for the government to spend what it was spending. Now we have to cover deficit spending every single year both for Social Security *AND* for everything else, and people wonder why our deficit is so high! It's because we were effectively hiding some spending by using the Social Security excess contributions to float the other stuff. We kicked the can down the road to when we knew the demographics for SS would be shit, and now they're shit, but we're STILL kicking the can saying everythings hunky-dory and will only be a problem in 2035 when the SSTF is exhausted. 

It's not "going to be" a problem in 2035. It's a damn problem NOW. 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on May 08, 2024, 04:15:17 PM
Raise the SS contributions and Medicare contributions. 

Pass a law that prevents any of that money from ever being touched, for any reason, period.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on May 08, 2024, 04:21:21 PM
Pass a law that prevents any of that money from ever being touched, for any reason, period.
That law already exists, and has existed since its inception.

Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on May 08, 2024, 04:27:34 PM
That law already exists, and has existed since its inception.


Please cite this law, because if it exists, it is clearly faulty and not enforceable.

I've heard this before. No teeth.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: betarhoalphadelta on May 08, 2024, 04:31:00 PM
Raise the SS contributions and Medicare contributions.

Pass a law that prevents any of that money from ever being touched, for any reason, period.
Problem is that you're mentally sticking with this stupid "trust fund" idea. It's unnecessary. The government doesn't need to save for a rainy day. It needs to set tax rates that fund its current obligations. 

The simple fact is that the SS/MC tax rates should be actuarially set based upon the demographic mix necessary to raise revenue and then pay recipients. I say jettison that the idea that you need to "save ahead" for the future of the program entirely. 

Set a process that every 5 years, the government determines the projected outlays for SS/MC, and sets the SS/MC taxes necessary for the next 5 years to meet that level of revenue. Any extra goes to the general fund. Any shortfall is made up by the general fund. Repeat. Perhaps you can put in kickers such that if for a 5 year period they were incorrect about the balance between the two, the taxes for the next 5 year period are maybe higher or lower based on the percentage shortfall or overage to try to make it a self-correcting mechanism (and not play politics with the tax rates). 

But we don't need a trust fund... And we don't need what you're suggesting, a lock box (hmm, where have I heard that one before?)...
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on May 08, 2024, 04:34:12 PM
That's a reasonable idea IFF there isn't going to be a major hump down the road, as there is with Baby Boomers.  So long as the demographics are fairly even and predictable, it should work.  You might need a small buffer that could be dipped into on occasion, and replenished later.



Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on May 08, 2024, 04:40:47 PM
Problem is that you're mentally sticking with this stupid "trust fund" idea. It's unnecessary. The government doesn't need to save for a rainy day. It needs to set tax rates that fund its current obligations.

The simple fact is that the SS/MC tax rates should be actuarially set based upon the demographic mix necessary to raise revenue and then pay recipients. I say jettison that the idea that you need to "save ahead" for the future of the program entirely.

Set a process that every 5 years, the government determines the projected outlays for SS/MC, and sets the SS/MC taxes necessary for the next 5 years to meet that level of revenue. Any extra goes to the general fund. Any shortfall is made up by the general fund. Repeat. Perhaps you can put in kickers such that if for a 5 year period they were incorrect about the balance between the two, the taxes for the next 5 year period are maybe higher or lower based on the percentage shortfall or overage to try to make it a self-correcting mechanism (and not play politics with the tax rates).

But we don't need a trust fund... And we don't need what you're suggesting, a lock box (hmm, where have I heard that one before?)...
And you trust the government to accomplish this? With all due respect, and I mean that whole-heartedly, dream on.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: betarhoalphadelta on May 08, 2024, 04:48:52 PM
And you trust the government to accomplish this? With all due respect, and I mean that whole-heartedly, dream on.
Well it's better than running a program in massive deficits and saying "hey, there's no actual problem here; look at this nifty trust fund!"

You come up with an idea "don't let anyone touch that money"--which is essentially what happened. The money was parked in the absolute safest possible investment it could have been. T Bills. As safe as cash (since the only way it would fail is a Treasury default and in that case the cash itself would be worthless), and even earning interest! 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on May 08, 2024, 04:54:05 PM
Well it's better than running a program in massive deficits and saying "hey, there's no actual problem here; look at this nifty trust fund!"

You come up with an idea "don't let anyone touch that money"--which is essentially what happened. The money was parked in the absolute safest possible investment it could have been. T Bills. As safe as cash (since the only way it would fail is a Treasury default and in that case the cash itself would be worthless), and even earning interest!
Well, I didn't come up with the idea, so there's that. The fact that it was stolen from, to me, is criminal.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on May 08, 2024, 05:01:53 PM
The money was not stolen, and by law, can only be invested in special T bills.  Nobody stole the money.

The reason the TF is going under is unrelated to any of that.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: betarhoalphadelta on May 08, 2024, 05:04:24 PM
Well, I didn't come up with the idea, so there's that. The fact that it was stolen from, to me, is criminal.
Sorry. Based on your response, I realize that the way I phrased that made it likely that it would be interpreted exactly opposite to my meaning.

My point was that nobody "touched" that money, or "stole from" that money, etc. They just weren't going to keep it in cash. It was put into the safest most trustworthy asset that it could possibly be put into. And that asset has been sitting there ready for the Social Security program to access whenever it needs it (and it has been drawing it down for I think most of the last decade).

The problem is that the asset that it was invested in, while extraordinarily safe for the Social Security program, makes claims on American taxpayers either now (taxes) or in the future (deficit spending). 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on May 08, 2024, 05:10:31 PM
The money was not stolen, and by law, can only be invested in special T bills.  Nobody stole the money.

The reason the TF is going under is unrelated to any of that.
OK, so they borrowed from it.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on May 08, 2024, 05:11:44 PM
The SSTF invests in special Treasury bills, by law.  As noted, there is no safer investment in the world, and they get interest on it.  It would be silly to hold it in cash somewhere, somehow.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: betarhoalphadelta on May 08, 2024, 06:09:30 PM
OK, so they borrowed from it.
Or more accurately, the SSTF invested in safe interest-bearing bonds instead of trying to hold their money in cash and watching its value erode due to inflation. 

BTW my issue is not that the SSTF invested the money. That's prudent. My issue is that they invested it in an asset that will make claims on *me* to pay it back. 

I.e. if Zambia had a social security system and invested its excess contributions in US Treasury Bills, that would be good for their system and for the future Zambian generations. Because when they need to draw down that investment, it's on US taxpayers to fund it (by retiring that debt). 

If the SSTF had been invested in Swiss sovereign bonds or in an ETF based on the S&P 500 or even in US corporate debt, it would be good for the system and good for the American taxpayer, because "someone else" is now the one on the hook to pay back that debt when it gets drawn down. 

But when you put it in US T Bills, it's the US taxpayer that has to pay it back. 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: betarhoalphadelta on May 08, 2024, 06:13:50 PM
And I highlight again that this is why I hate the whole SSTF. If smart guys like you two don't really see the corrosive effect it has on honestly discussing the issue, what are the dumb-dumbs of the world going to do? 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on May 08, 2024, 06:19:43 PM
I only use somewhat different verbiage. 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: betarhoalphadelta on May 08, 2024, 06:53:21 PM
I only use somewhat different verbiage.
I dunno...

The link you provided that set me off on this kept highlighting the point at which the trust fund is depleted as if it's a meaningful date. That to me buys into the falsehood that the SSTF is actually meaningful. And it obscures the fact that right now, SS shortfalls are not being paid by drawing down some "trust fund" full of cash, they're being paid by deficit spending.

Tomorrow Congress could pass a bill extinguishing the SSTF, cancelling all of those T Bills, and committing to paying current benefits and... Nothing of import would change. The question is and always will be "will we continue to pay benefits at X level?", not "when does the SSTF run out of assets?"

Be even acknowledging the SSTF and treating it with import, we're obscuring the ultimate question, which is how we're going to pay for all these retireee benefits. 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Gigem on May 08, 2024, 07:56:59 PM
I think what brad is trying to say is that it’s like the words strongest person.  Lets just say this man weighed 350 lbs, but he can bench press and lift 500-600 lbs. 

No matter how hard he tries, he can’t lift himself up off the ground. He can lift way more than his weight, but it literally wouldn’t matter if he could lift 1,000,000 lbs. he cannot lift himself up, because he cannot exert a net force on himself. 

Same thing with SSTF. It all comes out of the same body, no matter what you call it. 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: MrNubbz on May 08, 2024, 09:24:56 PM
And you trust the government to accomplish this? With all due respect, and I mean that whole-heartedly, dream on.
Ed Zachery,great insight by Bwarb but this government has turned into the fuedal lords and their fiefdom's that this country fought/opposed/detested
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: MrNubbz on May 08, 2024, 09:28:59 PM
The SSTF invests in special Treasury bills, by law.  As noted, there is no safer investment in the world, and they get interest on it.  It would be silly to hold it in cash somewhere, somehow.
well can I invest in them and if so how bad will they hammer me at maturity and take their cut,err - I mean tax
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on May 08, 2024, 10:21:13 PM
Individuals cannot buy them. 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on May 09, 2024, 10:01:00 AM
This is the best time for a Roth conversion, experts say (cnbc.com) (https://www.cnbc.com/2024/05/09/best-time-for-a-roth-conversion.html)

They say after retirement and before RMDs kick in.  You can't RMD money into a Roth, it won't count.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on May 09, 2024, 10:10:03 AM
Very much considering that now. We'll take a huge tax hit, but we think taxes are as low as they will ever be again right now. Meeting with my advisor next week.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on May 09, 2024, 10:18:33 AM
Let me know what he advises.  I'm in a similar situation.  I hesitate to do much converting because of the steep penalty I'd pay in higher taxes.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: FearlessF on May 09, 2024, 10:26:23 AM
I should probably convert just enough to keep me from bumpin the next tax bracket

that wouldn't be a lot, but otherwise I wait until I retire

hopefully, that's in a few years
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on May 09, 2024, 10:27:24 AM
I should probably convert just enough to keep me from bumpin the next tax bracket

that wouldn't be a lot, but otherwise I wait until I retire

hopefully, that's in a few years
That's probably what we will do too.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on May 09, 2024, 10:27:33 AM
Edging into the next tax bracket isn't a disaster of course, though it could push you into higher Medicare payments.  The tax bracket thing is widely misunderstood.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on May 09, 2024, 10:28:08 AM
I understand it well.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on May 09, 2024, 10:30:05 AM
2024 Federal Income Tax Brackets and Rates for Single Filers, Married Couples Filing Jointly, and Heads of Households

CSV EXCEL PDF PRINT
[th]Tax Rate[/th]
[th]For Single Filers[/th]
[th]For Married Individuals Filing Joint Returns[/th]
[th]For Heads of Households[/th]
10%$0 to $11,600$0 to $23,200$0 to $16,550
12%$11,600 to $47,150$23,200 to $94,300$16,550 to $63,100
22%$47,150 to $100,525$94,300 to $201,050$63,100 to $100,500
24%$100,525 to $191,950$201,050 to $383,900$100,500 to $191,950
32%$191,950 to $243,725$383,900 to $487,450$191,950 to $243,700
35%$243,725 to $609,350$487,450 to $731,200$243,700 to $609,350
37%$609,350 or more$731,200 or more$609,350 or more



Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: FearlessF on May 09, 2024, 10:47:33 AM
going from 24% to 32% would suck

I think
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on May 09, 2024, 10:50:00 AM
going from 24% to 32% would suck

I think
If you just barely edged into it, it would hardly matter.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on May 09, 2024, 10:51:23 AM
going from 24% to 32% would suck

I think
Depends on how far and deep you dip in.

We would have to get well into the 37% bracket to convert everything and that is NOT happening on my watch.

We will go right up to the top of the 24% barrier and will keep doing so until we are done.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on May 09, 2024, 10:51:39 AM
If you just barely edged into it, it would hardly matter.
Correct.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: Cincydawg on May 09, 2024, 11:19:20 AM
If you get into the 32% tax bracket by say $1,000, your extra tax payment would be 32% of the thousand less 24%, or another 8%, or $80.



Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on May 09, 2024, 11:26:22 AM
Correct. No big deal. Now, if you get in at over $100K, that's real money.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: betarhoalphadelta on May 09, 2024, 11:26:57 AM
going from 24% to 32% would suck

I think
Not really. You understand the concept that if you're single and you make $200K, that not the entire $200K is taxed at 32%, right? The first 191,950 is taxed at the lower rates shown there. Only the $8050 between $191,950 and $200,000 is taxed at 32%. 

So going from an AGI of $190,000 to $200,000 would increase your annual tax bill by $3,044 but would put an additional $6,956 in your pocket. 

Making a higher income is pretty much universally good, even if you get bumped up into a higher tax bracket. 

EXCEPT when we look at things like this:

Depends on how far and deep you dip in.

We would have to get well into the 37% bracket to convert everything and that is NOT happening on my watch.

We will go right up to the top of the 24% barrier and will keep doing so until we are done.

In this case Badge is not "earning" more money via his job, so it's not like he's contemplating whether or not he wants a raise. But these conversions get counted as income, so he is making a choice to do them now or to defer them to later. 

Which is why it's best to only do as much each year as necessary to remain in the 24% bracket. Pulling forward everything else and bumping him into the next bracket just gives more money to the taxman while NOT actually benefiting him. Since it's merely a conversion from one form of investment to another and doesn't have to happen in 2024, it makes sense to do them at the lowest possible tax rate. 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: betarhoalphadelta on May 09, 2024, 11:36:53 AM
going from 24% to 32% would suck

I think
The proper comparison of Badge's situation would be something like this... I think you're in sales, right?

Let's say you're getting to the very end of the year, and you've had a really good year. You're RIGHT on the border of that 24/32% split. In fact, we'll say that you're actually at $191,949.99 in 2024 income. You have a $20,000 commission check coming to you. You know that due to market conditions (or whatever), you're probably not going to have as good of a year next year. 

You have a choice between taking that commission check on Dec 31 2024 counting as this year's income, or taking it on Jan 1 2025 and counting it as next year's income. In this case you would choose to defer it until Jan 1. If you take it Dec 31 you'll be taxed at 32% on that money, and giving $6,400 to the IRS. If you take it Jan 1--and don't earn over 191,950 in 2025--you'll be taxed 24% on that money, giving $4800 to the IRS. You save $1600 in taxes by deferring it to the next tax year. 

But these types of situations are unusual. In most cases, when you make more money, it's a good thing even if you end up in a higher tax bracket. 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on May 09, 2024, 11:40:55 AM
It's also important to consider your earning power. 

Let's say you have a $1 million in an IRA. Let's say you're making 20 percent on that. So, in a year, you'd have $1.2 million.

If you do a conversion and say lose $200K to taxes, now you have $800K to invest. In a year, at 20 percent, you'd have $960K.

You are short $240K.

It's a tough balance.

Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: betarhoalphadelta on May 09, 2024, 11:44:31 AM
It's also important to consider your earning power.

Let's say you have a $1 million in an IRA. Let's say you're making 20 percent on that. So, in a year, you'd have $1.2 million.

If you do a conversion and say lose $200K to taxes, now you have $800K to invest. In a year, at 20 percent, you'd have $960K.

You are short $240K.

It's a tough balance.
True, but if you have the same tax rate, if you wait and do the conversion on $1.2M next year after you've made that gain, they'll take that exact same $240K in taxes.

But if the conversion on $1.2M bumps you into a higher tax bracket or Congress raises taxes, they'll take >$240K in taxes. 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: 847badgerfan on May 09, 2024, 11:52:08 AM
Like I said, it's a balance.

We don't plan on touching anything anytime soon, and when we do, we will both be on max SS income, plus my wife's pension. My buyout should be done by then and invested.

So, what we take out, if anything, will be measured by the top of the tax bracket we'll be in without taking anything out.
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: FearlessF on May 09, 2024, 11:54:37 AM
yes, I understand

I was also talking about converting IRS to ROTH

I'd love to actually make enough to bump into the higher bracket with commissions 
Title: Re: Retirement / What am I working for?
Post by: MrNubbz on May 09, 2024, 01:08:06 PM
Let's say you have a $1 million in an IRA. Let's say you're making 20 percent on that. So, in a year, you'd have $1.2 million.
I've got that under the rugs in the house and some sealed in the the zip locks up on the garage gutters. Problem is I seem to be 800K short