| FIRST TEAM | ||||
| QB | J.T. Barrett | Ohio State | ||
| RB | Saquon Barkley | Penn State | ||
| RB | Jonathan Taylor | Wisconsin | ||
| WR | D.J. Moore | Maryland | ||
| WR | Simmie Cobbs | Indiana | ||
| TE | Mike Gesecki | Penn State | ||
| T | Jamarco Jones | Ohio State | ||
| G | Beau Benzschawel | Wisconsin | ||
| C | Billy Price | Ohio State | ||
| G | Michael Jordan | Ohio State | ||
| T | David Edwards | Wisconsin | ||
| - | ||||
| DL | Maurice Hurst | Michigan | ||
| DL | Nick Bosa | Ohio State | ||
| DL | Tyquan Lewis | Ohio State | ||
| DL | Rashan Gary | Michigan | ||
| LB | Josey Jewell | Iowa | ||
| LB | T.J. Edwards | Wisconsin | ||
| LB | Tegray Scales | Indiana | ||
| DB | Denzel Ward | Ohio State | ||
| DB | Josh Jackson | Iowa | ||
| DB | Nick Nelson | Wisconsin | ||
| DB | Godwin Igwebuike | Northwestern | ||
| - | ||||
| K | Griffin Oakes | Indiana | ||
| P | Ryan Anderson | Rutgers | ||
| RET | Saquon Barkley | Penn State | ||
| - | ||||
| SECOND TEAM | ||||
| QB | Trace McSorley | Penn State | ||
| RB | J.K. Dobbins | Ohio State | ||
| RB | Justin Jackson | Northwestern | ||
| WR | Stanley Morgan | Nebraska | ||
| WR | J.D. Spielman | Nebraska | ||
| TE | Troy Fumagalli | Wisconsin | ||
| T | Michael Dieter | Wisconsin | ||
| G | Ben Bredeson | Michigan | ||
| C | Brian Allen | Michigan State | ||
| G | Sean Walsh | Iowa | ||
| T | Mason Cole | Michigan | ||
| - | ||||
| DL | Chase Winovich | Michigan | ||
| DL | Sam Hubbard | Ohio State | ||
| DL | Alec James | Wisconsin | ||
| DL | Joe Gaziano | Northwestern | ||
| LB | Devin Bush | Michigan | ||
| LB | Joe Bachie | Michigan State | ||
| LB | Paddy Fisher | Northwestern | ||
| DB | D'Cota Dixon | Wisconsin | ||
| DB | Marcus Allen | Penn State | ||
| DB | Rashard Fan | Indiana | ||
| DB | Lavert Hill | Michigan | ||
| - | ||||
| K | Rafael Gaglianone | Wisconsin | ||
| P | Blake Gillikin | Penn State | ||
| RET | Parris Campbell | Ohio State |
| Offensive Player of the Year | RB Saquon Barkley, Penn State |