CFB51 College Football Fan Community
The Power Five => Big Ten => Topic started by: ELA on December 11, 2017, 09:03:10 AM
-
| | FIRST TEAM | | |
| QB | | J.T. Barrett | | Ohio State |
| RB | | Saquon Barkley | | Penn State |
| RB | | Jonathan Taylor | | Wisconsin |
| WR | | D.J. Moore | | Maryland |
| WR | | Simmie Cobbs | | Indiana |
| TE | | | | |
| T | | | | |
| G | | | | |
| C | | | | |
| G | | | | |
| T | | | | |
| | | - | |
| DL | | | | |
| DL | | | | |
| DL | | | | |
| DL | | | | |
| LB | | | | |
| LB | | | | |
| LB | | | | |
| DB | | | | |
| DB | | | | |
| DB | | | | |
| DB | | | | |
| | | - | |
| K | | | | |
| P | | | | |
| RET | | | | |
| - | | | |
| | SECOND TEAM | | |
| QB | | Trace McSorley | | Penn State |
| RB | | J.K. Dobbins | | Ohio State |
| RB | | Justin Jackson | | Northwestern |
| WR | | Stanley Morgan | | Nebraska |
| WR | | | | |
| TE | | | | |
| T | | | | |
| G | | | | |
| C | | | | |
| G | | | | |
| T | | | | |
| | | - | |
| DL | | | | |
| DL | | | | |
| DL | | | | |
| DL | | | | |
| LB | | | | |
| LB | | | | |
| LB | | | | |
| DB | | | | |
| DB | | | | |
| DB | | | | |
| DB | | | | |
| | | | |
| | | | |
-
PSU
-
It might depend of whether you consider blocking as an important skill for a TE. Gesicki can catch anything within 10 yards of his position, but he can't block anything.
-
Kind of surprised Fant has 3 votes. Thought he was clear #3. Big gap from 2 to 3 and then again from 3 to 4.
-
They must've watched his game vs the Buckeyes.
-
Kind of surprised Fant has 3 votes. Thought he was clear #3. Big gap from 2 to 3 and then again from 3 to 4.
He's getting the Buckeye vote.
-
Went with Gesicki,Fumagalli is right there however
-
Fant is also getting the Husker vote
big game in Lincoln and the kid is from Omaha
-
Well.. he's not getting any love from UW fans.
He accounted for zero of Iowa's 66 total yards that day.
-
Well there you have it.
They didn't get him the ball, and only had 66 total yards as a result.
-
I think he averaged 66 yards per touch vs the Huskers and Buckeyes
-
Noah Fant had 10 TD catches this season.
-
That's pretty good for having 28 catches total.
-
Noah Fant had 10 TD catches this season.
yeah but all 10 of them were against Ohio State so it doesn't count. ;P
I went Gesicki. I'd put Troy from UW at #2.
-
Fumagalli is the better blocker, Fant is the more talented receiver. Fumagalli is my #2, but I don't see a large gap between him and Fant.
-
Fumagalli is the better blocker, Fant is the more talented receiver. Fumagalli is my #2, but I don't see a large gap between him and Fant.
Wow.
-
Wow.
Ditto.
-
I think thats what many are missing about Noah Fant.
He may have had only 28 catches, but he averaged 17 yards per catch for 486 yards and 10 TDS. The guy had a lot of big explosive plays that led to a lot of scores.
-
I voted Fumagalli. Maybe it makes me a homer, but here's my case.
He's a bigger part of the offense (targeted 24.7 percent of the time to Gesicki). We have a good indication this isn't because he's been fed the ball short because his catches keep UW ahead of or move the chains 52.2 percent of the time, compared to 47 for Gesicki. That also comes through with the fact Troy is better on yards per target, 7.7 to 7.3, despite the fact Gesicki catches 73.9 percent of balls thrown his way to 64.2 for Troy. I give bonus points for the fact UW's third-down passing was mostly throw to 81, and UW was a very good 3rd down team despite being a middling third-down running team (from the numbers, I get the sense Gesicki was used often as a short ball/screen guy, but that could just be a quirk). Throw in the fact Fum is generally regarded as a better blocker (I think?) and seemed cut and dried on my end.
The Iowa kid is interesting. He blows the other two away in yards per catch and target. He's a really big play guy, granted his catch rate is below 50 percent. Seems like a good deep target. I dunno where you put a big-play guy whose blocking is considered sub-par. It's a weird one to slot.
-
This one still tied, otherwise I'll break it momentarily