Your School's All-Time Team, as per my game

[OrangeAfroMan]

Since we're just going on best single season, I'll adjust my picks.
Thanks
Oklahoma

QB (1) - Baker Mayfield (2017)

RB (4) - Billy Sims (1978), Greg Pruitt (1971), Samaje Perine (2014), Quentin Griffin (2002).  I dropped Adrian Peterson because he had a ton of carries and his ypc stat was not as good as the guys I've included.  

This is the beauty of the exercise, you can either try to maximize your team (as you've done) or include the big name for cool factor...neither is wrong.

[OrangeAfroMan]

I'll do Pitt's - Dorsett is left off because I'm old but not so old that I ever saw him play for pitt obv. same for players like Ditka

QB: Marino

RB (this is difficult): James Conner, Curtis Martin, LeShaun McCoy, Craig Heyward

WR: Fitzgerald, Antonio Bryant, Tyler Boyd, Julius Dawkins

K: Blewitt, maybe Kessman but he was just a FR

P: Andy Lee

KR: Raphael Arujo-lopes

PR: Raphael Arujo-lopes

Pass Rushers: Aaron Donald, Hugh Green, Chris Doleman

DBs: Darrell Revis.......and ummm Jordan Whitehead?, Steve Isreal?, Tim Lewis?

Need 2 more WR/TE.

[FearlessF]

Yeah, I saw that.  I hadn't heard of him and looked him up.  What I meant was that you'd want him to be on some run play cards, so you'd have to drop a RB (only 4 ball-carriers per team).

but, he's probably the only QB that had a better average than the top backs

[OrangeAfroMan]

but, he's probably the only QB that had a better average than the top backs

I get it, it's smart.  But imagine you have the game and buy the all-time Nebraska set and there's no Frazier or Gill or Crouch.  You'd be bummed, right?  

[FearlessF]

I'd certainly be bummed if I bought the set and got my asre handed to me 90% of the time

[OrangeAfroMan]

LSU:

QB:  '06 JaMarcus Russell
RB:  '58 Billy Cannon, '13 Jeremy Hill, '15 Leonard Fournette, '16 Derrius Guice
WR/TE:  '01 Josh Reed, '86 Wendell Davis, '83 Eric Martin, '13 Jarvis Landry, '13 Odell Beckham Jr, '70 Andy Hamilton ('96 David LaFleur, if you need a TE)
Pass rush:  '16 Arden Key, '94 Gabe Northern, '89 Oliver Lawrence
Pass defense:  '78 Chis Williams, '88 Greg Jackson, '03 Corey Webster
K:  '10 Josh Jasper
P:  '97 Chad Kessler

[OrangeAfroMan]

I'd certainly be bummed if I bought the set and got my asre handed to me 90% of the time

Well that's why every all-time team would get the best defensive ratings - they're all going to be super-teams and should win a vast majority of the time vs regular teams and probably about 50% vs other all-time teams.  It'd all be in how you played and the luck involved in a dice roll.  I've played games where my amazing QB had 4 TD/0 INT and games where he's had 0 TD/2 INT.  
All-Time Nebraska could have you or me at QB and hold its own, lol.