qb - i like the stidham pick but i'll go with lock. full disclosure, i watched very little of his games, but looking at his stats AND who they came against, he came up big in the toughest games. his team didn't, but it wasn't for lack of his effort and effectiveness. vs au, uf, tenn, ark and uga, he was 91/154 (59%), 18 tds, 6 int. only bad games vs decent comp he had was vs usc.
rb - carry-on is the clear favorite here. as for rb #2, i'll take chubb. a bit of a career choice, but he had a really good year this year as well, and becoming the #2 all time sec rusher deserves some reward.
wr - brown, moore, ridley, chark and kirk all deserve a look. pick and 3 and you can have it, with brown likely the only lock based on stats alone. throw in ryan davis for au just for the stupidly good final 1/2 or 1/3 of season.
te - hurst from usc is only one i can think of.
oline - no idea, but i'd pick some combination of guys from msu, au, and uga. maybe uk as well. i have no idea how bama got 1 on the ap all sec, much less 3 on 1st team.
dline - payne from bama and thompson from uga are anchoring the middle for me. neither have the stats, but the inside guys almost never do. outside, i'd have holland and sweat from au and msu, respectively.
lb - evans from bama is similar to key i guess in that his stats suffer because of missed time. but if i'm making a best sec team, i'm not leaving him off if healthy, regardless of stats. only other guys not yet mentioned is gates from ole miss. had a very solid year stats wise.
s - homer in me, but i really do think bama has 2 of the best safeties in nation not just sec.
cbs - no arguments against those already listed. would maybe add wallace from bama as potential replacement. 3 ints, 12 pbu, 15 pass def. those are good numbers. having said that, for cb's the ones with the best stats are usually the #2 cb on their own team, and that is the case with wallace. he played really well for bama, but he was definitely our #2 cb. but if we're balancing stats with play, he's best candidate from bama here.
p - can't go wrong with either scott from bama or the uf kicker. i'll take and argue for scott all day long, though, cause i'm a homer. only allowed 4 punt returns all season, for a combined total of 5 yards. no one in sec comes close to that. (uf p is 28 returns for 306 total yards).
k - having looked at nothing, i'll take au kicker.
pr/kr - kirk gets a lot of love here, but i'll take chark.
