I liked the Big Ten prior to adding PSU. That said, I think they were a strong add. And once they were added and the conference became odd-numbered and imbalanced, I felt like Nebraska was a good fit athletically and culturally [if not academically], and also balanced the East with the West. And 12 made room for a CCG, which I don't need, but I don't absolutely hate.
So I'd be fine with the 10 schools prior to adding, or the 12 schools post. Anything beyond 12 it ceases to feel like a unified conference, and the post-12 additions don't "fit" very well with the Big Ten's historic identity.
However, the bigger structure is that I want the postseason to go back to pre-BCS. Ideally even before the Bowl Alliance or Bowl Coalition.
So either 10 or 12 teams in the conference is fine, paired with 1997 (or 1991) bowl alignment.