I think all of this focus on academics is a little misleading.
Upthread
@bwarbiany posted a link which stated that Stanford's median football player "who reported scores" got an 1800 on the SAT and 26 on the ACT. Those a good scores. An 1800 on the SAT is 81st percentile and a 26 on the ACT is 83rd percentile. The thing is that Stanford's average for all students is 2220 on the SAT and a score of 2080 is only the 25th percentile of Stanford students. Those Stanford football players with 1800 SAT scores are 280 points behind a 25th percentile Stanford Student and 420 points behind an average Stanford student.
Furthermore, I strongly suspect that the football averages (at all schools, not just Stanford) are inflated by the inclusion of walk-ons. I've never found absolute confirmation of this, but wherever you see the football player scores you never see "scholarship football players", instead you see it as "all football players". My suspicion is that the walk-ons that we have never heard of probably have normal scores for the institution in question which means that the scholarship football players are even lower than the "average football player" because that average is propped up by higher-scoring walk-ons.
This gap is frankly an embarrassment for all of our schools.
Here is
a link that I have posted before that lays out the enormous gap between football scores and scores of other students at major schools. Michigan (997), Purdue (974), Indiana (973), and Iowa (964) all made the top-10 which is great. The problem is that those scores aren't great and they are the best in the country. Everybody else is even worse.
There is a good reason why a lot of high-end academic schools with decent football/basketball programs hide most of their athletes in what are effectively "athlete only" majors. They have to because otherwise the athletes couldn't possibly keep up with the general student population.
Look at Stanford:
- 1800 "football average" is 81st percentile nationally.
- 2080 is 25th percentile of Stanford students is 96th percentile nationally.
- 2220 is average for all Stanford students is 98th percentile nationally.
- 2360 is 75th percentile for all Stanford students is 99.8th percentile nationally.
Bottom line, Stanford's "average" football player is in the smartest ~ 1 in 5. Stanford's average student is in the smartest 1 in 50. That is a HUMONGOUS gap. Stanford's 1800 scoring football players cannot possibly keep up academically with the "real" Stanford students.