It's hard to mesh eye test with resume evenly, if that's even a goal for someone. There are sold and/or impressive wins, but there are also close wins vs weak teams. There are close losses to strong teams, even multiple games like that and more blowouts vs cupcakes than is comfortable.
I'm not criticizing anything, no one should without posting their own rankings. But for Baylor:
3 pretty solid wins
vs
close wins vs Rice, ISU, TxTech, WV
Back to the abstract - what's "better" - the 3 point win vs WV or the 3 point loss to an Oregon? The goal is to win the game, but with all of the variables and lack of cross-section data means we have to value this stuff on the same plane. Meh, I type all this and we all know it already.