I generally am a fan of smaller cars. Maybe that comes from driving minivans for years. The GTI fit the bill for me, fun and engaging to drive, good fuel economy, stick shift, decent room for two of us, the backseat was tight for two adults. The two downsides is egress and the ridiculous maintenance bill the tried to tag me with.
I could have handled the bill going elsewhere of course. My wife wanted a car easier to get in and out of, so that turned the spade. The Tuscon is comfortable, and boring, very boring. It's small enough to be OK in city traffic, which oddly we drive in a lot.