The Caddy SUVs are not very competitive IMHO. I would get them on occasion as a loaner from the dealer, I didn't like them. It is good to drive various competitive vehicles and see what fits. Pay attention to seat comfort and position, that is oft overlooked.
I tested the small Mercedes SUV as a Diesel. It was OK, but the Honda is probably a better deal/value, I think.
In general I dislike SUVs anyway. I was amazed how many SUVs (miniutes) are apparent in France today.