Perhaps the BEST B1G Forum anywhere, here at College Football Fan Site, CFB51!!!

Now I'm confused, but I'm glad I was right, somehow.

Now I'm confused, but I'm glad I was right, somehow.

I think this is exactly what the committee will say on selection Sunday.

I think this is exactly what the committee will say on selection Sunday.

Now this I'll agree with.

i have no idea what the MAC has to do with it.

The example was NIU -- that's not forgivable.  They're in the MAC, 7th place to be exact.

But my fundamental disagreement with you is you forgiving a shitty loss due to a "good win." 

 Fair enough.  I'm not sure what your measuring stick is.  So make a case for every current 2 loss SEC team, and tell me who gets in.  Maybe that will help me see your side.

The first time Georgia or Alabama lost, that seemed like a "good win."  The second time, it can only diminish the "good win" status.

So now it just ends up as a circle jerk of "credibility" from "good wins" from teams that keep on piling on the losses.

Yep.  And this is what the committee is wading through every week.

Y

just need 7 for at large slots

Big Ten has 3 w/o shitty losses - assuming Oregon is the champ and takes a top 4 seed
PSU, tOSU, & the Hoosiers

SEC has 3 w/o shitty losses - assuming Texas is the champ
A&M, UGA, & the Cocks

Just need one more..........
ND has a shitty loss
Clemson if they win out
Miami if Georgia Tech wins out over UGA
SMU if Clemson takes the ACC top 4 seed
the Big 12 has nuttin
the PAC? nuttin

yup, tough to find 7
and might be tougher in a couple weeks

Well first of all, Texas isn't a 2-loss SEC team.  No case needs to be made there, unless/until a second loss occurs.

And second, I really don't feel like spending the time to do that, no offense intended.  That's the selection committee's job, not mine.  If they want to pay me, I'll go through that exercise for them.

Now, now......don't knock it until you've tried it.

The time you've spent shooting holes in my logic, you could've already made your case.  

Where do I mail the check to?

Better shrink the playoff back to 4 teams.  There aren't 12 great teams. 

the 12 team playoff was all about allowing non-great teams a seat at the table - I understand

an ungreat team is gonna slide in once in a while in the 7 at-large slots
that's OK with me to a certain extent
if you are an undeserving team with a shitty loss - sorry, cry if you'd like