Lest you folks think your opinions don't matter and that there's no point in putting them out in the world.... Y'all convinced me to give it a go.
We rented Jaws on Friday night. Wife hadn't seen it in years, but said it was a favorite of hers. She was a little surprised I'd never seen it. She reminded me that her brother really likes it and says he watches it every several years, because she knows he and I have a lot of similar tastes.
I don't really care about the shark looking bad or any of that. It was fine. Which is how I felt about the movie in general. It was fine.
I fell asleep for a good bit of the middle--granted, I was absolutely wore out Friday evening, so it may not say anything about the movie itself. I enjoyed the beginning well enough. I woke up to a really good scene, which for me, was the highlight of the movie, which was Quint, Brody and Hooper in Quint's boat getting drunk the night before the movie's climax. He talked about having served aboard the USS Indianapolis and what he lived through, which I just happened to know a little bit about through dumb luck, because my paternal grandfather served in the Navy during WW2 in the Pacific theater, though not on the Indianapolis. I thought incorporating a real-life horrific tragedy into the backstory of Quint's character was a good move on the movie's part, and like I say, it was a great scene.
The climax and ending were about what I expected.
Overall, I see the appeal, particularly if you watched it growing up. I doubt I'll ever revisit it to catch the middle I missed, but I'm not sorry I rented it.