I think it would be cool, although that's a LOT of work on OAM...
For example, I'd probably either pick 2003 or 2004 Purdue. I'm quite sure he hasn't made sets for those teams yet, and probably will have little to no interest in that set in the future.
But if he's up for it, I'd be good.
OAM--I do have a question. 2004 Purdue, for example, was a strange year. Kyle Orton started the season absolutely on FIRE. But in the Wisconsin game he got a hip pointer, and then while recovering [and playing through] that hip pointer he got one on the other hip, so by the time of the Michigan game that year he was playing through double hip pointers... His play suffered until he got healthy later in the year.
I assume you base stats on full year play, so perhaps it'd be a better choice to use 2003 when the team was mostly healthy?