It’s also Worth noting, they’ve had more than a few dipshit mayors, and used to be run by an insane tyrant from the shadows. And somehow it still stands.
With "insane tyrant from the shadows" are you referring to Robert Moses or some other Democrat Machine politician with whom I am less familiar?
I'll say this:
Yes, it still stands, but it can REALLY change things for the better or worse. I visited NYC in the spring of 1994 and it was a shithole. The crime was so bad that left-wing NYC elected Republican Rudy Giuliani to consecutive terms followed by Bloomberg who was nominally a Republican (and was very Republican, Law-and-Order) on crime for three terms. After my experience in 1994 I NEVER wanted to go back but my wife convinced me to take her to the Macy's Parade in the mid 2010s and I was pleasantly surprised. 20 years of the adults being in charge had REALLY cleaned the place up.
To put this in perspective, here is how NYC voted in the Presidential elections around that time:
- 1992: 69% Clinton (D), 24% Bush (R): D>R by 45%
- 1996: 77% Clinton (D), 17% Dole (R): D>R by 60%
- 2000: 78% Gore (D), 18% Bush (R): D>R by 60%
- 2004: 75% Kerry (D), 24% Bush (R): D>R by 51%
- 2008: 79% Obama (D), 20% McCain (R): D>R by 59%
- 2012: 81% Obama (D), 18% Romney (R): D>R by 63%
- 2016: 79% Clinton (D), 18% Trump (R): D>R by 61%
McCain in 2008 and Trump in 2016 did carry Staten Island and Staten Island was generally reasonably close in the other elections but the rest of the Boroughs were consistently Democratic blowouts.
My point is that crime was so bad that the VERY left leaning (see above) New Yorkers set aside their ideology to put actual adults in charge of the City to get the massive crime problem under control and it worked extremely well.
The murder rate in NYC in 1994 was through the roof and that is indicative of the rest of their crime rate. In addition to murders: Rapes, violent robberies, muggings, etc were all through the roof to the extent that it hurt their tourism industry. By the time Bloomberg left office the high crime days were so far in the past that the NYC electorate forgot why they elected adults in the first place and went back to electing morons. Unsurprisingly, crime has been rising.