As for myself, I chose option #2.
My thoughts:
Option #2, 8-1 vs unranked, 1-2 vs top-13:
I picked this because I'm willing to assume that the loss to an unranked team is a fluke and this team has shown an ability to beat playoff caliber teams.
Option #3, 7-2 vs unranked, 2-1 vs top-13:
The second loss to an unranked team is troubling but it is offset by a second quality win.
Option #1, 9-0 vs unranked, 0-3 vs top-13:
It is great for them that this team beat the teams they *should* beat but they've had three chances against playoff caliber teams and they went 0-fer. I see this as a machine-like predictable team with a very high floor but a low ceiling.
Option #4, 6-3 vs unranked, 3-0 vs top-13:
The three quality wins are fantastic but three losses to unranked teams is more than a fluke, it is a pattern. Something is wrong with this team that causes them to just suck on their bad days. This team obviously has a high ceiling but, as I see it, their floor is very low.