There's been like 20-some odd 1 vs 2 matchups, most of which were never given the GOTC moniker, either before or after.
Fearless is listing some great games, but (I assume) was no build-up or GOTC talk before the 84 OB, as it was assumed Nebraska would roll that Miami team of Johnny-come-latelies.
.
I recall 1993 FSU vs ND given that build-up.
I'm curious about 1996 Florida vs FSU, as I was too "in it" to know the national interest accurately. Both 10-0, both smoking everyone on the schedule. Huge rivals in the last regular season game, like 06 UM-OSU. Was there any GOTC talk at all?
I think there was. I would have been a LOT more interested in that one had tOSU not lost to Michigan the week prior, 11/18 poll:
- 10-0 Florida
- 10-0 Ohio State
- 9-0 Florida State
- 10-0 Arizona State
- 9-1 Nebraska (lost early to ASU)
- 9-1 Colorado (lost early at home to Michigan, revenge for the hail mary game a few years earlier)
- 9-2 Penn State (lost to tOSU and Iowa)
Then Ohio State lost to Michigan. That set up UF/FSU as a 1v2, the 11/25 poll was:
- 10-0 Florida
- 10-0 Florida State
- 11-0 Arizona State
- 9-1 Nebraska
- 9-1 Colorado
- 10-1 Ohio State
The regular season was complete for ASU and Ohio State who were already locked into facing each other in the Rose Bowl (first bowl game I ever attended).
#5 Colorado visited #4 Nebraska on Friday (11/29) and #1 Florida visited #2 Florida State on Saturday with the home teams winning both games (HFA matters). Thus the new poll and games remaining before the bowls as of December 2 was:
- 11-0 FSU: Regular season complete.
- 11-0 ASU: Regular season complete, facing #5 tOSU in Pasadena.
- 10-1 UNL: vs nr Texas in St. Louis in the brand new Big12 CG.
- 10-1 UF: vs #11 Bama in Atl in the SECCG.
- 10-1 tOSU: Regular season complete.
All other teams were eliminated because nobody was going to jump the tOSU/ASU winner from behind. Florida beat Bama in ATL but the Cornhuskers got upset by the Longhorns in St. Louis so the December 9 poll (heading into the bowls) was:
- 11-0 FSU: vs #3 UF in the Sugar Bowl.
- 11-0 ASU: vs #4 tOSU in the Rose Bowl.
- 11-1 UF: vs #1 FSU in the Sugar Bowl.
- 10-1 tOSU: vs #2 ASU in the Rose Bowl.
As an Ohio State fan I was hoping for a blowout of ASU in the Rose Bowl and a REALLY close UF win over FSU in a crappy looking game in the Sugar Bowl. All other teams were eliminated.
A couple things about that game:
For one thing the poll didn't come out until Monday back then and FSU didn't ascend to #2 until the poll AFTER Ohio State's loss to Michigan so that was only #1 vs #2 for five days. A lot of the other games on this list were anticipated as #1 v #2 for a month or more.
Another thing is that the Bowl Coalition went into effect in 1992 so by 1996 the idea of #1 vs #2 wasn't the rarity that it had been a decade earlier. The AP Poll started in 1936 and it took almost three decades for the top two teams to meet in a bowl. #1 vs #2 was a rarity before that. By 1996 it wasn't.