Perhaps the BEST B1G Forum anywhere, here at College Football Fan Site, CFB51!!!

Clemson   8   0   1.000   12   1   .923      North Carolina   7   1   .875   11   2   .846
NC State   5   3   .625   8   4   .667      Miami   5   3   .625   8   4   .667
Florida State   5   3   .625   7   5   .583      Virginia   5   3   .625   7   5   .583
Boston College   3   5   .375   7   5   .583      Pitt   4   4   .500   8   4   .667
Louisville   3   5   .375   4   8   .333      Virginia Tech   4   4   .500   8   4   .667
Wake Forest   2   6   .250   5   7   .417      Duke   2   6   .250   5   7   .417
Syracuse   1   7   .125   3   9   .250      Georgia Tech   2   6   .250   4   8   .333
                                          
Oklahoma   9   0   1.000   13   0   1.000                        
TCU   6   3   .667   9   4   .692                        
Iowa State   6   3   .667   8   4   .667                        
Oklahoma State   5   4   .556   7   5   .583                        
Texas   5   4   .556   6   6   .500                        
West Virginia   5   4   .556   6   6   .500                        
Baylor   3   6   .333   6   6   .500                        
Texas Tech   3   6   .333   6   6   .500                        
Kansas State   3   6   .333   5   7   .417                        
Kansas   0   9   .000   1   11   .083                        
                                          
Indiana   8   1   .889   12   1   .923      Minnesota   6   3   .667   8   5   .615
Ohio State   8   1   .889   11   1   .917      Wisconsin   6   3   .667   9   3   .750
Penn State   6   3   .667   8   4   .667      Northwestern   5   4   .556   7   5   .583
Maryland   4   5   .444   7   5   .583      Purdue   5   4   .556   6   6   .500
Michigan   4   5   .444   7   5   .583      Nebraska   4   5   .444   6   6   .500
Rutgers   2   7   .222   5   7   .417      Iowa   3   6   .333   6   6   .500
Michigan State   2   7   .222   4   8   .333      Illinois   0   9   .000   2   10   .167
                                          
Oregon   9   0   1.000   12   1   .923      Arizona State   7   2   .778   9   4   .692
Oregon State   5   4   .556   8   4   .667      USC   6   3   .667   8   4   .667
Stanford   4   5   .444   6   6   .500      Utah   6   3   .667   8   4   .667
Washington   4   5   .444   6   6   .500      Colorado   5   4   .556   7   5   .583
Washington St.   3   6   .333   6   6   .500      UCLA   4   5   .444   5   7   .417
California   0   9   .000   2   10   .167      Arizona   1   8   .111   2   10   .167
                                          
Georgia   7   1   .875   11   2   .846      Auburn   7   1   .875   11   2   .846
Florida   6   2   .750   10   2   .833      Alabama   6   2   .750   10   2   .833
Kentucky   4   4   .500   8   4   .667      Texas A&M   6   2   .750   10   2   .833
Tennessee   3   5   .375   6   6   .500      Mississippi St.   6   2   .750   9   3   .750
Vanderbilt   2   6   .250   5   7   .417      Ole Miss   3   5   .375   7   5   .583
Missouri   2   6   .250   4   8   .333      Arkansas   2   6   .250   6   6   .500
South Carolina   1   7   .125   2   10   .167      LSU   1   7   .125   5   7   .417
                                          
Cincinnati   7   1   .875   10   2   .833                        
Houston   6   2   .750   8   4   .667                        
Central Florida   6   2   .750   10   2   .833                        
Memphis   6   2   .750   10   2   .833                        
East Carolina   4   4   .500   7   5   .583                        
Tulane   4   4   .500   5   7   .417                        
Tulsa   3   5   .375   6   6   .500                        
SMU   3   5   .375   5   7   .417                        
Temple   3   5   .375   5   7   .417                        
South Florida   2   6   .250   3   9   .250                        
Navy   0   8   .000   2   9   .182                        
                                          
Florida Atlantic   5   3   .625   7   6   .538      UAB   7   1   .875   11   2   .846
Charlotte   4   4   .500   7   5   .583      Southern Miss   6   2   .750   7   5   .583
M. Tennessee   4   4   .500   5   7   .417      Louisiana Tech   4   4   .500   6   6   .500
Marshall   4   4   .500   5   7   .417      Rice   4   4   .500   6   6   .500
W. Kentucky   4   4   .500   5   7   .417      UTSA   4   4   .500   6   6   .500
FIU   3   5   .375   5   7   .417      North Texas   3   5   .375   5   7   .417
Old Dominion   2   6   .250   3   9   .250      UTEP   2   6   .250   6   6   .500
                                          
Buffalo   7   1   .875   11   2   .846      Toledo   8   0   1.000   11   2   .846
Miami(Ohio)   4   4   .500   6   6   .500      C. Michigan   6   2   .750   7   5   .583
Ohio   3   5   .375   6   6   .500      W. Michigan   5   3   .625   7   5   .583
Bowling Green   2   6   .250   3   9   .250      E. Michigan   4   4   .500   7   5   .583
Kent State   2   6   .250   3   9   .250      Ball State   4   4   .500   5   7   .417
Akron   1   7   .125   2   10   .167      Northern Illinois   2   6   .250   3   9   .250
                                          
Wyoming   6   2   .750   10   3   .769      Nevada   8   0   1.000   11   2   .846
Air Force   5   3   .625   7   5   .583      San Diego State   5   3   .625   9   3   .750
Boise State   4   4   .500   4   8   .333      Hawaii   5   3   .625   8   5   .615
New Mexico   3   5   .375   5   7   .417      Fresno State   4   4   .500   7   5   .583
Colorado State   3   5   .375   4   8   .333      San Jose State   3   5   .375   5   7   .417
Utah State   1   7   .125   2   10   .167      UNLV   1   7   .125   2   10   .167
                                          
Troy   6   2   .750   9   4   .692      Louisiana   6   2   .750   10   3   .769
Appalachian St.   6   2   .750   9   3   .750      South Alabama   3   5   .375   6   6   .500
C. Carolina   5   3   .625   8   4   .667      Texas State   3   5   .375   5   7   .417
Ga. Southern   3   5   .375   4   8   .333      Arkansas State   3   5   .375   4   8   .333
Georgia State   3   5   .375   3   9   .250      UL Monroe   2   6   .250   3   9   .250
                                          
Liberty   9   3   .750                                 
Notre Dame   9   3   .750                                 
BYU   8   4   .667                                 
Army   7   4   .636                                 
Connecticut   3   9   .250                                 
Massachusetts   3   9   .250                                 
NM State   2   10   .167                                 

Well, this simulated season has been weird indeed, UGA loses two games, one to Auburn, and then beats them in the CG (again).  I guess I'd take it.

Then somehow Indiana is B1G champion.  Then somehow UNC is ACC champion.

This is going to be a mess at the top.  Indiana, Oregon, Oklahoma, and UGA?

My thoughts, which got buried above

Well, 3 playoff spots are locked up.

• #1 Oklahoma, undefeated
• #2 Oregon, 1 loss, Pac 12 champ
• #3 Indiana, 1 loss, Big Ten champ

Then for the final spot

• Clemson, lost in ACC Championship
• OSU, lost regular season to Indiana, didn't play in Big Ten Championship
• Georgia, 2 loss SEC Champ
• North Carolina, 2 loss ACC Champ

I would assume the four 2 loss non SEC Champs (Auburn, Alabama, Florida, A&M) would all be out

Thoughts?

It may hinge on how bad UGA lost to Clemson and Auburn, and how good they looked beating Florida (and UK).  They would have just three wins over ranked teams and two losses to ranked teams and an SEC crown.  Optics.

Well, this simulated season has been weird indeed, UGA loses two games, one to Auburn, and then beats them in the CG (again).  I guess I'd take it.

Then somehow Indiana is B1G champion.  Then somehow UNC is ACC champion.

This is going to be a mess at the top.  Indiana, Oregon, Oklahoma, and UGA?

this would be interesting
tough season for the SEC and ACC
also tough for the Big West

I'd take it even-though the Husker's final record wasn't great - 6/6 going bowling!

wins vs the Badgers and Hawkeyes would be worth it for this fan living in Iowa 

I see it as a tough call either way. 

Yes, but right or wrong, I think the committee chooses the path of least resistance.  I think that's why OSU got in over either TCU or Baylor.  Whatever reasons they gave, I think the ultimate reason was not having to pick one over the other.  IIRC one won head to head, but the other had the better resume?  Can't remember which was which

Yes, but right or wrong, I think the committee chooses the path of least resistance.  I think that's why OSU got in over either TCU or Baylor.  Whatever reasons they gave, I think the ultimate reason was not having to pick one over the other.  IIRC one won head to head, but the other had the better resume?  Can't remember which was which

Yeah, eye test said TCU was better and they had the more impressive resume.  Baylor won the head to head by coming back from like 20 down in the 4th.