since the online recruiting sites era (2002-present) Michigan has landed five 5* QB's. They rank overall as...
1) Bryce Underwood (#1 player overall and #1 QB in 2025 class)
2) Shea Patterson (#4 player overall and #1 QB in 2016 class) *didn't technically sign with Michigan, transferred in*
3) Ryan Mallet (#5 player overall and #2 QB in 2007 class)
4) Chad Henne (#18 player overall and #3 QB in 2004 class)
5) J.J. McCarthy (#25 player overall and #5 QB in 2021 class)
Recruiting sites definitely nailed both McCarthy & Henne rankings, both were great college QB's for Michigan and 1st and 2nd rd picks respectively. Mallett (RIP) was only at Michigan the true frosh year and then transferred out because Lloyd Carr and retired and RichRod came in and was changing the offensive philosophy completely. He was a HELL of a player in college for his new team Arkansas and probably would've been drafted much higher if not for all the off-field stuff. Shea Patterson was pretty average and went undrafted by the NFL. I'd say that one was a miss by the sites. 3 out of 4- 75% hit rate ain't bad.