I don't like it in football, but the rosters are so big, that it was never totally about the personalities to me.
Basketball was about the personalities and the tournament. This sort of kills that. I think the one that did it to me was when Eastern Washington nearly upset Kansas in a 3-14 game in maybe 2022? They had 3 stud underclassmen, including 2 brothers. Then all 3 immediately left. I think the PG went to Gonzaga, and the brothers went to Oklahoma State. Steph Curry is probably at Duke for his junior and senior years now.
I think I posted earlier that when Auburn and Kansas were #1 and #2, their combined starting lineups were 9/10 transfers. If you are a fan of a team, it's probably less of an issue than if you are a fan of the sport.
I don't mind the NIL stuff. Michigan paying Bryce Underwood does not bother me one bit. The transfer portal is what is killing college athletics, at least to me.