Perhaps the BEST B1G Forum anywhere, here at College Football Fan Site, CFB51!!!

We should do a poll.

Which group contains the best defensive player in college football history?

A)  Aidan Hutchinson
.
B)  EVERYONE ELSE IN HISTORY

you are acting like an irrational woman. who said Aidan Hutchinson was the greatest defensive player in college football history? 

he's not even the best defensive player to ever play at his own school. ever heard of charles woodson? 

you are acting like an irrational woman. who said Aidan Hutchinson was the greatest defensive player in college football history?

he's not even the best defensive player to ever play at his own school. ever heard of charles woodson?

MaximumSam did.

maybe the most overrated play ever by one of the most overrated college football players ever right here...SEC! SEC! SEC! GrAyesT rEcRuiT EvErrrRRRR tho.

LT Taylor Lewan runs on an angle right and into the defensive tackle, the TE to the left of Lewan tries to follow Lewan and neither one of them lay a finger on Clowney- and he darts into the backfield completely untouched and completely unblocked bc of bungled OL play and he blows up literally a 5-foot, 6-inch, 170 pound Vincent Smith and people lose their shit. Not impressive at all- and it probably made the guy the #1 pick in the draft and his rep lived off this stupid play for a year plus.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2JYx-_eXQa4

Where did I specify only sacks matter?  You're inventing shit now.  Please stop. 

Stop what? You are going on about the best statistical seasons. Statistical seasons I assume means the stats that we generally keep - tackle, sacks, tackles for loss, interceptions, fumble recoveries, that sort of thing. Am I wrong on that? Aren't sacks and tackles for loss the glory stats for front seven players? Don't wax on about statistical seasons then in the same breathe say you aren't talking about the stats.

Stop what? You are going on about the best statistical seasons. Statistical seasons I assume means the stats that we generally keep - tackle, sacks, tackles for loss, interceptions, fumble recoveries, that sort of thing. Am I wrong on that? Aren't sacks and tackles for loss the glory stats for front seven players? Don't wax on about statistical seasons then in the same breathe say you aren't talking about the stats.

Oh, you admit it.  Fantastic!

How many past highest-rated defensive players were Heisman finalsits? 

As in "highest rated" by PFF.  You know, what he and I were talking about. 

PFF, as far as I can tell, has only looked at college players since 2014. 

2021: Hutchinson, Anderson, Jordan Davis
2020: No one
2019: Chase Young
2018: Quinnen Williams
2017: Roquan Smith
2016: Jonathan Allen
2015: No one
2014: Scooby Wright

Okay, so 25% of the black players and half the white dudes.  

Don't get mad at me because this small sample agrees with me.