Hutchinsons injury has made this tough. He was an elite end. Id argue best in the league, as a top 10 pass rusher, who could also defend the run. But hes been a shell of himself post injury in a contract year. I think you have to pay him, and hope a full offseason gets him back, but if he cant come back to what he was after this injury, thats a bad contract.
If he wasnt a hometown hero, I think you let him walk if he holds out for big money. But hes an in state guy, who went to UM, and sells a ton of jerseys. You have to take the risk